How to Compare DSM-5-TR Criteria in Psychiatric Case Studies
Need help with this assignment?Get an original answer from a qualified tutor — from $10/page.
Get it written →Comparing DSM-5-TR criteria is how you prove your diagnosis in an NRNP 6635 case study. Rather than stating “the patient meets criteria,” strong evaluations show, criterion by criterion, how the patient’s findings match or do not match each candidate diagnosis. This guide explains how to compare DSM-5-TR criteria in psychiatric case studies using a structured, table-based approach.
Quick answer
For each candidate diagnosis, check core symptoms, the required number of symptoms, duration, distress or impairment and exclusion criteria, then match each element to evidence from your case. A side-by-side table makes the comparison clear. Summarize criteria in your own words, cite the DSM-5-TR and conclude whether each diagnosis is supported, partially supported or not supported.

The patient in this guide is fictional and is used for study purposes only. Diagnostic criteria are summarized in our own words; consult the DSM-5-TR directly for exact criteria, and base your evaluation on your assigned case.
The Five Elements to Compare
- Core symptoms: the essential features, such as depressed mood or anhedonia for a major depressive episode.
- Symptom count: how many symptoms are required.
- Duration: minimum time periods, which often distinguish related disorders (for example, brief psychotic disorder, schizophreniform disorder and schizophrenia).
- Clinical significance: distress or functional impairment.
- Exclusions: not attributable to a substance or medical condition and not better explained by another mental disorder.
Each element comes from the DSM-5-TR (American Psychiatric Association, 2022). Summarize criteria in your own words and cite the manual; do not copy criteria verbatim at length.
Example Comparison Table
| DSM-5-TR element (summarized) | Generalized anxiety disorder | Panic disorder | Patient evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core feature | Excessive, hard-to-control worry about multiple areas | Recurrent unexpected panic attacks | Worries daily about work, health and finances; no sudden attacks reported |
| Associated symptoms | At least 3 of: restlessness, fatigue, poor concentration, irritability, muscle tension, sleep disturbance | Persistent concern about attacks or behavior change for at least 1 month | Restlessness, muscle tension, poor sleep, irritability (4) |
| Duration | At least 6 months, more days than not | At least 1 month after an attack | 8 months |
| Exclusions | Not due to substance or medical condition; not better explained by another disorder | Same | Caffeine use moderate; TSH normal |
| Verdict | Supported | Not supported | GAD is primary |
The table makes your reasoning visible: GAD is supported on every element, while panic disorder lacks its core feature. For more on anxiety presentations, see NRNP 6635 anxiety disorders comprehensive evaluation.
Duration Distinctions to Know
| Disorders | Key duration difference (summarized) |
|---|---|
| Brief psychotic disorder / schizophreniform / schizophrenia | 1 day to less than 1 month / 1 to 6 months / at least 6 months including prodromal or residual phases |
| Manic vs. hypomanic episode | At least 1 week (or any duration if hospitalized) vs. at least 4 consecutive days |
| Acute stress disorder vs. PTSD | 3 days to 1 month after trauma vs. more than 1 month |
| Major depressive episode vs. persistent depressive disorder | At least 2 weeks vs. at least 2 years in adults |
Writing the Comparison in Paragraph Form
If your template requires paragraphs, follow the same order: name the diagnosis, state the criteria met with evidence, state criteria not met or uncertain and give your verdict. Mention what additional data would confirm the diagnosis, such as collateral history or labs.
Common Mistakes
- Listing criteria without linking them to patient evidence.
- Ignoring duration requirements.
- Skipping exclusion criteria, especially substance use.
- Using DSM-5 rather than DSM-5-TR terminology.
To build your list of candidates, see how to develop three differential diagnoses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I copy DSM-5-TR criteria into my paper?
Summarize criteria in your own words and cite the DSM-5-TR. Long verbatim copying can raise originality concerns.
What if the case lacks information for a criterion?
State that the information was not available and explain how you would obtain it.
Should I compare criteria for all three differentials?
Yes. Each differential should be evaluated against its criteria, even those you rule out.
Get Help Comparing DSM-5-TR Criteria at Collepals
Comprehensive psychiatric evaluations take time, and NRNP 6635 often requires a new one every few weeks. Collepals.com supports PMHNP students with:
- Guidance on organizing your case into the comprehensive psychiatric evaluation template.
- Help comparing DSM-5-TR criteria and building three well-supported differential diagnoses.
- Current, evidence-based references formatted in APA 7.
- Model evaluations, case presentations and reflections you can study, plus editing and proofreading of your drafts.
Browse our free model assignments or learn more about our nursing assignment writing service.
Use Collepals examples as study guides and follow your university’s academic integrity and AI policies when you submit your own work.
More NRNP 6635 study guides
Collepals is an independent study resource and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Walden University. Course requirements, templates and rubrics change; always follow your current syllabus and course template. This article is educational and is not clinical advice for any individual patient.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed., text rev.). https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.books.9780890425787
Get a plagiarism-free answer to this question
Send us your instructions and we’ll match you with the best writer in your subject.
- 100% human-written, zero AI
- Turnitin report included
- Confidential — we never share your data
- Free revisions & refunds


