Joshua is a good-natured and intelligent 15-year-old male who was diagnosed with an aggressive bone cancer and underwent a below-the-knee amputation of his left leg. Joshua’s cancer metastas
Need help with this assignment?Get an original answer from a qualified tutor — from $10/page.
Get it written →Joshua is a good-natured and intelligent 15-year-old male who was diagnosed
with an aggressive bone cancer and underwent a below-the-knee amputation of
his left leg. Joshua’s cancer metastasized to his chest, skull, and lungs, and he
was readmitted a few months later for removal of the remainder of his left leg.
Joshua and your son have been friends at school for several years and you had
met Joshua many times before his illness. Since then, you have been his nurse
on occasion and he has talked to you about his disease. He has told you that
talking about it upsets his parents and makes his friends uncomfortable so it is
nice to have someone with whom he can be honest. In fact, you have always
been impressed with the level of maturity and insight he demonstrates. Joshua has been readmitted, his prognosis is grim, and he is experiencing a
great deal of pain. Although you have not been assigned to care for Joshua
during this admission, you are aware that members of the clinical team have
been uncomfortable with Joshua’s situation throughout his treatment. This is
because Joshua’s parents have requested that the health care personnel limit the
information they share with Joshua. This time, despite the many questions he
asks, Joshua has not been told the extent of the metastases or that he will likely
die within a few weeks. Members of the care team have frequently omitted
information and even lied to Joshua at the insistence of his parents and with the
reluctant agreement of his attending physician. Members of the care team have
questioned the unit director several times about this policy; however, she
continues to instruct them to respect the wishes of the parents to avoid any legal problems. Joshua’s parents also insist that he continue to receive every possible
intervention and another clinical trial is being considered.
One evening Joshua notices you in the hall and calls you into his room. He
confronts you and tells you he knows he is not being told everything. He says he
believes he is dying and, although it frightens him, he is ready to die. He has not
been able to attend school for several months; his friends no longer come to see
him; he knows his younger brother and sister get very little attention because of
him; and he is in nearly constant pain. He is tired of pretending to be “strong and
brave.” He has tried to talk to his parents but they refuse to even listen to him. He
says, “I trust you to tell me exactly what’s happening and what I need to do to
stop treatment, even if it is against my parents’ wishes.” As a nurse who has cared for Joshua in the past and who also knows him
personally, you are faced with the practical problem of how to respond to his
request to be told the truth of his condition and how to discontinue treatment.
The first step in any analysis will be to gather all relevant information so that
you are fully informed of the situation and its implications. For example, what
are the relevant organizational policies and are there legal requirements that
must be considered? Also, you may want to consider your professional code of
ethics to clearly identify whether there are particular expectations of you in this
situation as a member of the profession.
From this point, how you solve the problem will ultimately depend on the ethical
questions you ask and the ethical assumptions you consider. There is no one
right solution to the problem. Let us examine some of the ethical questions that
could be posed in relation to this case beginning with the ethical principles.
Should Joshua’s autonomy be considered and/or honored with respect to
his treatment? (respect for persons)
Is Joshua being needlessly harmed by withholding information and
continuing aggressive treatment? (nonmaleficence)
Are Joshua’s parents and physician acting in his best interests?
(beneficence)
Does Joshua have a moral right to be told the truth of his condition?
(veracity)
To whom do I, as a nurse, owe my loyalty? (fidelity)
Is Joshua being treated fairly and equitably? (justice)
Is the health care team caring for Joshua being treated fairly and
equitably? (justice)
Similar questions can be posed from each of the theoretical perspectives. An
ethic of duty will ask, “What are my duties in this situation and, if in conflict,
what duty should take precedence?” An ethic of consequence will ask, “What
action(s) will create the greatest benefit and cause the least harm?” An ethic of
character will rely heavily on your own moral intuition and ask “What should my
intentions be and what actions will serve the good?” Notice that this approach
requires you to define “the good” in this particular situation as part of your
analysis. Finally, an ethic of relationship will ask, “How can I best advocate for
Joshua while considering other important relationships between parents, the
physician, and my colleagues?”
Notice that each of the questions posed is highly relevant but quite different in
its focus and potential outcome. An ideal solution would address as many of
these issues as possible. Unfortunately, Joshua is sitting in front of you
expecting an answer now, which is why ongoing practice with ethical reflection
and analysis is so important to your practice. You will not always have the
luxury of time to explore your options so you need to be able to assess the
ethical dimensions of a situation quickly and effectively. How would you
respond to Joshua?
Get a plagiarism-free answer to this question
Send us your instructions and we’ll match you with the best writer in your subject.
- 100% human-written, zero AI
- Turnitin report included
- Confidential — we never share your data
- Free revisions & refunds