sociology
Need help with this assignment?Get an original answer from a qualified tutor — from $10/page.
Get it written →Question 2: Types of Capital
2) Interview someone about the types of capital (economic, social, cultural) available to them as they position themselves in society.
What is the role of capital in the attainment of social status and upward mobility?
Assess relative amounts of each type. How consistent are the types of capital? Explain.
Differentiate for capital that is inherited versus capital that is achieved by the individual. Elaborate on the capitals available or transmitted to them by family.
Where do they believe their capital places them in society? In particular, how do they perceive their status relative to other groups? Consider the way First Gen students position themselves in relation to more privileged students on campus.
Assess their views objectively: Where do you believe their capital places them in the status hierarchy? Your explanation should take account of all three types of capital.
Question #2 is a spin on the status hierarchies model. However, it substitutes the concept of capitals: status hierarchies are rank orders or gradations of capitals. Capitals are resources that can be invested in the attainment of status. Investment capital is necessary to compete for scarce rewards. However, capital is, itself, a scarce (zero sum) resource. For an overview of status capital see this video clip:
A Nation of Tribes (People Like Us, #1/YouTube); Joe Queenans Tour (People Like Us, #2/YouTube) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_Rtl3Y4EuI
Also see this article for a discussion of the concept of capitals: Pierre Bourdieu Bourdieus Theory of Class Distinction (on types of capital as resources for attaining status) http://www.liquisearch.com/pierre_bourdieu/bourdieus_theory_of_class_distinction
You may already be familiar with the concept of economic capital. This refers to the wealth available to engage in a particular endeavor. Lets say your subject wants to become a professional chef. How much money is needed to do this? Nowadays, chefs often have to enroll in expensive higher education programs like at the Culinary Institute of America or Johnson and Wales. It has become professionalized. There are extended apprentices. How much money is needed to open up a restaurant? Can a better location be afforded? Would a food truck be a cheaper option?
But, wait, other resources are necessary to attain status. Another type of capital is cultural, or the knowledge, skills, and values that are necessary to attain status. What credential does the aspiring chef have to have on her resume? How much experience is required? Annette Lareaus work highlights the role of parents cultural capital in childrens academic success. For an appreciation of speech style as cultural capital see the video You Talkin to Me? (NYT) https://www.nytimes.com/video/nyregion/1248069311927/you-talkin-to-me.html
There is, finally, social capital. This is who you know, or better who knows you! What names can be featured as references on a resume? Can the aspiring chef network his way into the profession and more specifically a position that is desired. These 3 types of capital are interrelated. For example, money can buy cultural capital and establish helpful connections. On the other hand, cultural and social capital can be cashed in, in other words, translated into economic capital. In any case, investing in status attainment requires building bridges for connections to the right people. An Ivy League College becomes important for First Gen students when there is no other network capital.
Keep in mind that capitals come in many shapes and sizes. The critical question is how capital matches up with the status to be attained. The video Ivy League Trailblazers is a good look at the different capitals at play in an elite university setting. Note the status inconsistency that characterizes the First Gen students. Also note that, in an meritocracy, the concept of capitals makes it possible to imagine upward social mobility. Graduating college furnishes the cultural and cultural capital needed to attain a job with greater rewards, in particular a higher income.
Ivy League Trailblazers, N. Osipova, (NYT 4.12.15) https://www.google.com/search?q=Ivy+League+Trailblazers&rlz=1C1AWFC_enUS755US755&oq=Ivy+League+Trailblazers&aqs=chrome..69i57.8118j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
_______
The article excerpted below examines the role of family capitals, in particular economic and cultural capital, and college admission. It focuses on the role of the college admission essay which has become controversial as another metric that reflects status privilege passes down by parents:
Its hard to disentangle social class from the college admissions process. The University of California system says its trying, announcing recently that its dropping consideration of the SAT and ACT. (It was part of a settlement in a lawsuit alleging that the tests are biased along lines of race, wealth and disability.)
More than half of U.S. colleges have made the tests optional for fall of 2021 admissions, according to FairTest, a group opposed to college entrance testing.
Because those tests are receiving so much scrutiny, its easy to overlook the influence of socioeconomic background on other admissions yardsticks.
Take the college essay. Its the most important soft factor and the fourth-most important overall factor after grades, curriculum strength and standardized test scores according to a 2019 survey of admissions employees.
But essays can be polished by a paid professional third party, or helped along by an upper-middle-class parent.
In another sign of the persistent pull of social class, a recent working paper from authors affiliated with the Student Narrative Lab at Stanford shows that essay content, when quantified through a computer program, is more highly correlated with household income than SAT scores are.
Researchers did not analyze whether these signs of status affect an essays quality, or speculate on whether they would make any difference in an evaluation by an admissions officer. But the research suggests that much of the socioeconomic information critics accuse the SAT of reflecting can also be found in essays.
The paper used software to classify essays written by nearly 60,000 applicants to the University of California system in 2016. The essays were quantified partly through syntax choices. The number of commas, total punctuation and longer words were correlated with higher household income, for example, although that doesnt necessarily equate to better writing.
The content was also quantified by word choice patterns, which are associated with particular topics. Admissions officials might not look more favorably upon essays written on certain themes, but its still notable that there are significant differences in the topics associated with higher and lower household incomes.
The topics associated more with students from higher-income households tended to be more thematically abstract: human nature, seeking answers and sensory experiences, said AJ Alvero, an education Ph.D. candidate at Stanford and one of the authors of the paper.
Topics more associated with lower-household-income students were about interpersonal relationships (e.g. multiple topics about family) and school issues like tutoring groups and time management.
A prior study by the same authors found similar patterns in income difference. A co-author of the study, Sonia Giebel, a Ph.D. candidate in sociology of education at Stanford, stressed along with the other authors that the content they identified was not a marker of essay quality, but pointed to a broader theme: Class patterns are likely to be present across all the elements used to make admissions decisions.
Poorer students, beyond writing their reality, may also be more likely to write about economic insecurity and abuse because of trying to meet perceived expectations. Even without specific guidance from admissions offices, they might feel obligated to sell their pain.
In contrast with much of the rest of the world, American admissions officers have a lot of discretion. Relying on elements like the essay gives them leeway to judge merit away from close scrutiny. The history of the so-called holistic approach looking at the whole applicant and not just academic metrics has not always been encouraging.
As Jerome Karabel wrote in his book The Chosen, relying on nonacademic characteristics had its origins in policies starting in the 1920s that aimed to limit the number of Jews admitted to elite universities. More recently, the discretion and opacity in admissions have been seen by some as harming high-scoring Asian students by penalizing them based on character or fit.
College Admissions Cant Escape Social Class Leanings, Arvind Ashok, NYT (5.27.2021) https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/26/upshot/college-admissions-essay-sat.html
________
See this article by Karyn Lacy which discusses the cultural capital that Black people have to possess and perform publicly – to buy a home in middle class, white neighborhoods:
When I talked two decades ago with more than 50 middle-class blacks who lived in the suburbs of Washington, I learned that their awareness of racial stereotypes led them to take on what I call public identities meaning they would strategically deploy cultural capital, including language, mannerisms, clothing and credentials in ways that brought their middle-class status firmly into focus. From their experiences attending integrated high schools, many of these people had come to believe this was key to managing racism in interactions with white people. They hoped it would tip the balance of their public interactions so that class would trump race and persuade white people to treat them fairly.
This is an idea related to code switching, a term used to describe the temporary shift from black English to standard English that some black people use to signal their appropriation of white, middle-class norms. But the public identities of the middle-class black people I studied involved more than language: They spanned everything from dress to conversation topics to the small details of workplace conduct.
As one of my subjects, Charlotte, put it, black people have two faces. So you know how to present yourself in the white world and you present yourself in the black world as yourself.
Theres good reason to believe that the public-identity behaviors I identified are as central a part of black middle-class life as ever. In a 2019 survey by the Pew Research Center, black respondents were more likely than any other racial group to report that they felt people were suspicious of them (65 percent), that people acted as though they were not smart (60 percent), that they were treated unfairly in hiring, pay or promotion (49 percent) and that they had been unfairly stopped by the police (44 percent).
In my research, several subjects told me that because of their awareness of the associations many make between black people and poverty, when they went shopping, they deliberately wore clothing that they hoped would convince white store clerks that they were not poor. To avoid being treated as potential shoplifters, they told me they would eschew attire that was at the time associated in the popular imagination with black culture like oversize gold earrings, baggy jeans and designer tennis shoes.
One subject, Philip, told me that he would go as far as to wear a suit. His belief was that when he was dressed as a professional, whites saw his class status first and responded to him as a member of that social group. Once he began to make purchases, he hoped that additional signifiers such as the kind of credit cards he carried and his ZIP code would assure store clerks that he was a member of the middle class.
Another subject, Jared, had a similar theory. When youre out in the world, you can be wearing grubbies, and youll be perceived a certain way if youre black, he said. He told me he imagined white people operated under a different public dress code: If you have money, its O.K. to wear rags.
Michael, a corporate manager, reported that he asserted his class status at work by refusing to answer his own telephone, always allowing calls to go through to his receptionist. He believed that taking on administrative tasks would reduce his social status in the workplace to that of a subordinate and leave room for his colleagues to see his race before his class and treat him with less respect.
The people I spoke to said they paid a price when they failed to perform these public identities. Once, dressed in sweatpants and a baseball cap, one of my subjects, Lydia, decided to view a model home. Right away, the real estate agent asked if the house was in her price range. Lydia knew that preapproval was not required for a tour and suspected that, because of her casual clothing combined with her race, the agent had mistaken her for a poor person who couldnt realistically make an offer. After learning the asking price, which was in her range, Lydia took charge of the interaction, putting on a public identity in the form of demonstrating assertiveness and knowledge of the market. Basically, I told her Ill take a look at the house and Ill let her know when Im finished, she explained. And she did.
Lydias experience echoed those of other house-hunting middle-class blacks who told me that they relied on firm language and knowledge of the market to manage interactions with white realty agents, hopeful that if they conveyed that they were informed and authoritative, they would be seen as members of the middle class and treated with respect.
Lydia wanted a home with a fireplace and she got it. However, she and other middle-class blacks I spoke to had no way to systematically assess how their housing searches compared with those of their white counterparts. While these interviews took place some time ago, and much has changed in the country since, black people have just as much reason to worry today. Decennial audit studies conducted by the Department of Housing and Urban Development, as well as an investigation conducted on Long Island and published by Newsday in 2019 (in which black and white trained testers using comparable financial identities visited the same real estate offices) have uncovered overwhelming evidence of housing discrimination against blacks, decades after the Fair Housing Act of 1968 made the practice illegal.
The people I talked to tended to focus more on their success in managing public interactions than they did on what these efforts cost them in time, energy and emotions. But engaging public identities exacts a psychological toll, as one study participant hinted when she described a relaxed day at work for her as one during which she didnt have to care what white people thought. And its worth mentioning that while my research focuses on middle-class black people, theres no doubt that black people of lower socioeconomic status who cant tap into these public identities have daily encounters that are even more unfair and demoralizing.
How to Convince a White Realtor Youre Middle Class, Karyn Lacy, NYT (1.22.20) https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/21/opinion/black-discrimination-study.html
________
This question asks you to illustrate the transmission of status from one generation to the next. See the transmission of capitals for Kamala Harris:
Sociologists emphasize the importance of the family for placing the individual in the social structure. Kamala Harris cited the importance of her parents and wider family for shaping her as a person (i.e., her self) in her speech accepting nomination as Vice President. Her mother was an immigrant from India and her father had emigrated from Jamaica. Both ancestries figured prominently in who Kamala became:
The couple soon had two daughters: Kamala, meaning lotus in Sanskrit, and Maya, meaning illusion.For Ms. Gopalan [Kamalas mother], it was important to maintain her Indian heritage. She introduced her daughters to Hindu mythology and South Indian dishes such as dosa and idli, and took them to a nearby Hindu temple where she occasionally sang. She also stayed close to her parents and flew back every few years to Chennai, on Indias southeast coast, where her parents had settled.
But as Ms. Harris explained in her memoir, published last year: My mother understood very well that she was raising two Black daughters. She knew that her adopted homeland would see Maya and me as Black girls.
How Kamala Harriss Family in India Helped Shape Her Values, J. Gettlemen and S. Raj, NYT (8.17.20) https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/16/world/asia/kamala-harris-india.html
Social class as well as race/ethnicity create different opportunity structures as individuals grow up (see the work of Annette Lareau on syllabus). Wealthy parents tend to have better educations and often work in managerial positions or careers that require creative problem solving, so they teach their children behaviors that are beneficial in these positions. This means children are effectively socialized and raised to take the types of jobs their parents already have, thus reproducing the class system (Kohn 1977). Both of Kamala Harriss parents had PhD degrees; her mother benefitted from a family tradition of encouraging women to pursue advanced professional education. Poor families usually emphasize obedience and conformity when raising their children, while wealthy families emphasize judgment and creativity (National Opinion Research Center 2008). This may occur because working-class parents have less education and more repetitive-task jobs for which it is helpful to be able to follow rules and conform. Children are also socialized to abide by, or conform to, gender norms.
Modern societies are characterized by the outsourcing of socialization. In other words, social institutions outside the family increasingly encroach on the family. This increased the likelihood of conflict between agents of socialization and for the individual. This also increases the likelihood of rebellion by individuals. Traditional cultures like the Amish and Hasidic Jews keep their distance from the dominant society by minimizing contact with mainstream education and mass media. The Amish, for example, do not make the electricity necessary for TV and internet connections available in their communities. Amish children meet only the minimum requirements for school attendance and are allowed to stop attending altogether at 14. Amish children learn to be Amish from their families. See article and book review below for the socialization of Donald Trump.
Like Father Like Son: President Trump Lets Others Mourn, Annie Karni and Katie Rogers, NYT (7.29.20) https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/28/us/politics/donald-fred-trump.html
7 Takeaways From Mary Trumps Book About Her Uncle Donald, Elisabeth Egan, NYT (7.8.20). https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/books/review/mary-trump-book-takeaways.html
Get a plagiarism-free answer to this question
Send us your instructions and we’ll match you with the best writer in your subject.
- 100% human-written, zero AI
- Turnitin report included
- Confidential — we never share your data
- Free revisions & refunds