RN Job Posting Comparison and Performance Appraisal Feedback Slides for Nurse Leaders
Need help with this assignment?Get an original answer from a qualified tutor — from $10/page.
Get it written →Nurse Leader Slides: Comparing Two RN Job Postings and Choosing the Best Performance Appraisal Feedback (Yoder-Wise & Sportsman, 2023)
Slide 1: Nurse leaders select well-qualified staff (Yoder-Wise & Sportsman, 2023). Find two posted RN positions for any inpatient unit and review their required competencies and qualifications. Analyze the general categories: are specific behaviors outlined, and which competencies are similar or different? Does each job description reflect current practice guidelines? Recommend two ways one description could be improved.
Slide 2: As nurse manager, you are appraising how an RN incorporates health teaching and promotion into discharge teaching using three criteria (teaching strategies, health promotion for self-management, a safe, clean, organized environment), rated 3 = achieves expectations, 2 = needs further development, 0 = unable to assess. The RN washed his hands, kept the room organized, gave written and verbal instructions in non-medical terms, paused for questions and recommended health promotion behaviors. Appraise three feedback options (a hallway “great job,” a scheduled private meeting with criterion-by-criterion ratings and goal setting, or a busy-shift office meeting reporting a total rating of 9), select the most appropriate, explain why and include at least one recommendation for improvement.
Two inpatient RN roles compared
Broad duties, few behaviors
Behavioral, standards-aligned competencies
Option 2: private, specific, two-way
Teach-back and a SMART goal
Download the slides with speaker notes (.pptx)
Model slides with speaker notes
Original example for study purposes (about 550 words). The download includes a title slide, the two required slides and a references slide. The job posting comparison describes typical inpatient postings; insert the two real postings you found and adjust the similarities and differences to match them.
Slide 1: Staff selection: Comparing Two RN Job Postings
- Posting A: Med-surg RN, [Hospital A]; Posting B: ICU RN, [Hospital B] (insert links)
- Shared categories: education, RN license, BLS, duties, physical demands
- Similar: patient assessment, care planning, teaching, teamwork, documentation
- Different: B adds ACLS, critical care experience, titrated drips; A adds BSN preference
- Few specific behaviors: most duties are broad (“provides safe care”)
- Partly current: mentions EBP and patient safety, not equity, informatics or teach-back
- Improve A: 1) write measurable behavioral competencies; 2) align with ANA standards and AACN Essentials
Speaker notes: I compared two RN postings for inpatient units: [insert hospital names, units and links]. Both are organized into the same general categories: qualifications such as education, licensure and basic life support certification, essential duties and physical requirements. The competencies are similar in assessment, care planning, patient teaching, teamwork and documentation. They differ in specialty requirements: the ICU posting requires advanced cardiac life support, prior critical care experience and skills such as managing titrated infusions, while the medical-surgical posting prefers a BSN and lists a broader patient load. Neither lists many specific behaviors; most duties are general statements such as ‘provides safe, effective care.’ The postings partly reflect current practice by mentioning evidence-based practice and patient safety, but they do not mention competencies emphasized in current guidelines, such as health equity, informatics, interprofessional communication tools and teach-back. I recommend two improvements to Posting A. First, rewrite duties as observable behaviors, for example ‘uses teach-back to confirm understanding before discharge.’ Second, align competencies with the ANA Scope and Standards of Practice and the AACN Essentials domains, such as quality and safety, informatics and person-centered care, so the description reflects current practice and supports fair, behavior-based interviews and appraisals.
Slide 2: Performance appraisal: Appraising Performance Feedback
- Best choice: Option 2
- Private, scheduled at a mutually convenient time
- Each criterion rated 3 with specific, observed evidence
- Two-way: invites the RN’s input and sets goals together
- Option 1: public, rushed, no evidence; Option 3: busy shift, summed “9” has no meaning
- Recommendation: add teach-back to confirm understanding and set one SMART growth goal (e.g., mentor a new nurse in discharge teaching)
Speaker notes: Option 2 is the most appropriate feedback. The manager schedules a time that works for both people and meets in a private setting, which shows respect and allows an honest conversation. Each criterion is rated separately, and every rating is supported with specific observations: individualized teaching in plain language, health promotion recommendations, hand hygiene and an organized room. The manager then invites the RN’s perspective and works with him to set goals, which makes appraisal a developmental process rather than a one-way judgment, as Yoder-Wise and Sportsman (2023) describe. Option 1 is given in a hallway, lacks specific evidence and treats the appraisal as paperwork. Option 3 interrupts a busy shift and reports a summed score of 9, which is not part of the 3-2-0 scale and gives the employee no information about specific behaviors. Even strong performers benefit from a growth recommendation. Although the RN paused for questions, he did not confirm understanding, so I would recommend using teach-back, having the client explain the instructions in their own words, and setting a goal such as mentoring a newer nurse in discharge teaching during the next review period.
References
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (2021). The essentials: Core competencies for professional nursing education. https://www.aacnnursing.org/essentials
American Nurses Association. (2021). Nursing: Scope and standards of practice (4th ed.). American Nurses Association.
Yoder-Wise, P. S., & Sportsman, S. (2023). Leading and managing in nursing (8th ed.). Elsevier.
Tip: link or screenshot the two postings in your notes so your instructor can verify them, and quote one vague duty from each posting to show what “no specific behaviors” means.
Frequently asked questions
Why isn’t Option 3 acceptable if it includes goal setting?
It interrupts a busy shift and reports a total of 9, which is not on the 3-2-0 scale and gives no criterion-specific evidence, so the RN cannot tell what he did well.
Should a high performer get recommendations?
Yes. Appraisal is developmental; even an employee who achieves every expectation benefits from a growth goal.
More model assignments posted today
Get a plagiarism-free answer to this question
Send us your instructions and we’ll match you with the best writer in your subject.
- 100% human-written, zero AI
- Turnitin report included
- Confidential — we never share your data
- Free revisions & refunds