HISTORY 101 Response paper
Need help with this assignment?Get an original answer from a qualified tutor — from $10/page.
Get it written →(The readings for this exercise are indicated below.)
So, what was revolutionary about the French Revolution? Raising this question is no mere word game, but takes us to the heart of a major historical debate. Almost immediately after the Revolution erupted in 1789, European (and even American) opinion divided sharply over this issue. While conservatives had recoiled in horror at the very notion of revolution, others (including some initial sympathizers) saw Frances revolutionary breakthroughs as yielding very little of lasting value. After all, one common argument went, the Revolutions most radical phases of 1792-94 ultimately gave way to the authoritarian rule of Napoleon Bonaparte. And in 1814, after Napoleons fall, France was once again ruled by kings (at least for a while). So what was revolutionary about that?
Not everyone shared this skeptical perspective. In France and Europe (and the U.S. and across the world), many saw in the dramatic events of the French Revolution the promise of a more democratic future a promise only partially realized at the time, but which inspired more radical and democratic political ideals and movements ever since.
This weeks readings address these issues from several perspectives, showing how the Revolution opened windows onto a variety of social and political questions freedom for religious minorities, for slaves and people of color, and for women that continue to animate our world to this day. These readings suggest, in other words, how we might view the Revolution as less a closed chapter than an open book, showing us how human dignity and freedom might be advanced if also sometimes laid low by collective political activity.
About the readings themselves, I propose three options for your papers:
a) the Abb Sieys selections point to the key issue prompting the Revolution in the first place: the demand by Frances Third Estate to be something. Your question: what, if anything, was revolutionary about Sieyss line of reasoning?
b) The Declaration of Rights of Man and Citizen reflects the attempt, by Frances revolutionaries, to balance its demands for universal rights with the need to maintain political order and stability. For all the sweeping affirmation of rights contained in this document, its authors were also trying to establish at least some limits on the exercise of these rights. What would be some examples of this balancing act, and how successful were the revolutionaries in pulling this off?
c) When Frances National Assembly declared the Rights of Man and Citizen in August 1789, its authors were mostly thinking of men, and moreover men pretty much like themselves educated and propertied and white. Yet to declare universal rights was to ensure that these ideas might be received by others in more far-reaching, inclusive ways, and debates erupted almost immediately over the rights of Caribbean slaves, religious minorities at home and, to some far-sighted observers, women as well. In broadening this debate over rights, the Jewish petitions and Society of the Friends of Blacks also deepened it, posing the question of human equality in new, more inclusive and challenging ways.
The question: how do these documents deepen our understanding of the relations between rights, freedom and citizenship? (You can restrict your response paper to mainly one or the other reading in working up your answer.)
The relevant readings for this exercise are in the Documentary Reader, pp. 31-38.
Emmanuel Joseph Sieys, “What is the Third Estate”; Declaration of Rights of Man and Citizens (1789); Petition of the Jews of Paris, Alsace and Lorraine (1790); and the 1790 “Address” from Society of the Friends of Blacks.
Get a plagiarism-free answer to this question
Send us your instructions and we’ll match you with the best writer in your subject.
- 100% human-written, zero AI
- Turnitin report included
- Confidential — we never share your data
- Free revisions & refunds