Develop critical thinking by looking into the two sides of an issue in Non-Profit Marketing
The intention is to develop critical thinking by looking into the two sides of an issue in Non-Profit Marketing. So, you will have to search on your own for an additional source to cite, and in 200 words, no less, answer the following questions:
What is (or are) the main message(s)? Be thorough and professional.
How does he/she/they support his/her/their arguments?
Pinpoint facts, stats, references, cite, if possible
What are the opposing views?
Cite and analyze
What are your views on the matter?
Balance the two positions.
In your own words, discuss the applicability of the piece.
Requirements: 200words
SocialMarketing:AnApproachtoPlannedSocialChangePHILIPKOTLERandGERALDZALTMANCanmarketingconceptsandtechniquesbeeffectivelyappliedtothepromotionofsocialobjectivessuchasbrotherhood,safedriving,andfamilyplanning?Theapplicabilityofmarketingconceptstosuchsocialproblemsisexaminedinthisarticle.Theauthorsshowhowsocialcausescanbeadvancedmoresuccessfullythroughapplyingprinciplesofmarketinganalysis,planning,andcontroltoproblemsofsocialchange.JournalofMarketing.Vol.35(July,1971),pp.3-12.IN1952,G.D.Wieberaisedthequestion”Whycan’tyousellbrotherhoodlikeyousellsoap?”1Thisstatementimpliesthatsellersofcommoditiessuchassoaparegenerallyeffective,while”sellers”ofsocialcausesaregenerallyineffective.Wiebeexaminedfoursocialcampaignstodeterminewhatconditionsorcharacteristicsaccountedfortheirrelativesuccessorlackofsuccess.Hefoundthatthemoretheconditionsofthesocialcampaignresembledthoseofaproductcampaign,themoresuccessfulthesocialcampaign.However,becausemanysocialcampaignsareconductedunderquiteun-market-likecircumstances,Wiebealsonotedclearlimitationsinthepracticeofsocialmarketing.AdifferentviewisimpliedinJoeMcGinniss’sbest-sellingbookTheSellingofthePresident1968.2Itsthemeseemstobe”Youcansellapresidentialcandidatelikeyousellsoap.”OnceNixongavetheword:”We’regoingtobuildthiswholecampaignaroundtelevision…youfellowsjusttellmewhatyouwantmetodoandI’lldoit,”theadvertisingmen,publicrelationsmen,copywriters,makeupartist,photographers,andothersjoinedtogethertocreatetheimageandtheaurathatwouldmakethismanAmerica’sfavorite”brand.”Theseandothercasessuggestthattheartofsellingcigarettes,soap,orsteelmayhavesomebearingontheartofsellingsocialcauses.PeoplelikeMcGinniss-andbeforehimJohnK.GalbraithandVancePackard-believeeverythingandanythingcanbesoldbyMadisonAvenue,whilepeoplelikeWiebefeelthisisexaggerated.TotheextentthatMadisonAvenuehasthispower,somepersonswouldbeheartenedbecauseofthemanygoodcausesinneedofaneffectivesocialmarketingtechnology,andotherswoulddespairoverthespectreofmassmanipulation.Unfortunatelytherearefewcarefuldiscussionsofthepowerandlimitationsofsocialmarketing.Itistheauthors’viewthatsocialmarketingisapromisingframeworkforplanningandImplementingsocialchange.Atthesametime,itispoorlyunderstoodandoftenviewedsuspiciouslybymanybehavioralscientists.Theapplicationofcommercialideasandmethodstopromotesocialgoalswillbeseenbymanyasanotherexampleofbusiness’slackoftasteandself-restraint.Yettheapplicationofthelogicofmarketingtosocialgoalsisanaturaldevelopmentandonthewholeapromisingone.Theideawillnotdisappearbyignoringitorrallingagainstit.1G.D.Wiebe,”MerchandisingCommoditiesandCitizenshiponTelevision,”PublicOpinionQuarterly,Vol.15(Winter,1951-52),pp.679691,atp.679.2JoeMcGinniss,TheSellingofthePresident1968(NewYork:TridentPress,1969).3
4Thisarticlediscussesthemeaning,power,andlimitationsofsocialmarketingasanapproachtoplannedsocialchange.First,thiswillrequiredelineatingthegenericnatureofmarketingphenomenaandsomerecentconceptualdevelopmentsinthemarketingfield.Thiswillbefollowedbyadefinitionofsocialmarketingandanexaminationoftheconditionsunderwhichitmaybecarriedouteffectively.Theinstrumentsofsocialmarketingaredefined,followedbyasystemsviewoftheapplicationofmarketinglogictosocialobjectives.WhatisMarketing?Thefollowingstatementtestifiesthatthereisnouniversalagreementonwhatmarketingis.Ithasbeendescribedbyonepersonoranotherasabusinessactivity;asagroupofrelatedbusinessactivities;asatradephenomenon;asaframeofmind;asacoordinative,integrativefunctioninpolicymaking;asasenseofbusinesspurpose;asaneconomicprocess;asastructureofinstitutions;astheprocessofexchangingortransferringownershipofproducts;asaprocessofconcentration,equalization,anddispersion;asthecreationoftime,placeandpossessionutilities;asaprocessofdemandandsupplyadjustment;andmanyotherthings.sInspiteoftheconfusingjumbleofdefinitions,thecoreideaofmarketingliesintheexchangeprocess.Marketingdoesnotoccurunlesstherearetwoormoreparties,eachwithsomethingtoexchange,andbothabletocarryoutcommunicationsanddistribution.Typicallythesubjectofmarketingistheexchangeofgoodsorservicesforothergoodsorservicesorformoney.Belshaw,inanexcellentstudyofmarketingexchangeanditsevolutionfromtraditionaltomodernmarkets,showstheexchangeprocessinmarketingtobeafundamentalaspectofbothprimitiveandadvancedsociallife.4Giventhatthecoreideaofmarketingliesinexchangeprocesses,anotherconceptcanbepostulated,thatofmarketingmanagement,whichcanbedefinedas:Marketingmanagementistheanalysis,planning,implementation,andcontrolofprogramsdesignedtobringaboutdesiredexchangeswithtargetaudiencesforthepurposeofpersonalormutualgain.Itreliesheavilyontheadaptationandcoordinationofproduct,price,promotion,andplaceforachievingeffectiveresponse.s3MarketingStaffoftheOhioStateUniversity,”AStatementofMarketingPhilosophy,”JOURNALOFMARKETING,Vol.29(January,1965),p.43.4CyrilS.Belshaw,TraditionalExchangeandModernMarkets(EnglewoodCliffs,N.J.:Prentice-Hall,Inc.,1965)..5PhilipKotler,MarketingManagement:Analysis,PlanningandControl,SecondEdition(EnglewoodCliffs,N.J.:Prentice-Hall,Inc.,1972).JournalofMarketing,July,1971Thusmarketingmanagementoccurswhenpeoplebecomeconsciousofanopportunitytogainfromamorecarefulplanningoftheirexchangerelations.Althoughplannedsocialchangeisnotoftenviewedfromtheclient’spointofview,itinvolvesverymuchanexchangerelationshipbetweenclientandchangeagent.”Thepracticeofmarketingmanagementasappliedtoproductsandserviceshasbecomeincreasinglysophisticated.Theresponsibilityoflaunchingnewproductsonanationalbasisinvolvingtheinvestmentandriskofmillionsofdollarsandtheuncertaintiesofconsumerandcompetitorresponses,hasledtoanincreasedrelianceonformalresearchandplanningthroughouttheproductdevelopmentandintroductioncycle.Marketingmanagementexaminesthewants,attitudes,andbehaviorofpotentialcustomerswhichcouldaidindesigningadesiredproductandinmerchandising,promoting,anddistributingitsuccessfully.Managementgoesthroughaformalprocessofstrategydetermination,tacticalprogramming,regionalandnationalimple-6ArthurH.Niehoff,ACasebookofSocialChange(Chicago:Aldine,1966);WarrenG.Bennis,KennethD.BenneandRobertChin,ThePlanningofChange(NewYork:Holt,Rinehart&Winston,1969).•ABOUTTHEAUTHORS.PhilipKotlerisA.MontgomeryWardProfessorofMarketingattheGraduateSchoolofManagement.NorthwesternUniversity.HeistheauthorofMarketingManagement:Analysis,PlanningandControlandMarketingDecisionMaking:AModel,BuildingApproach.ProfessorKotlerisalsoadvisoryeditoroftheHolt,RinehartandWinstonMarketingSeries,formerchairmanoftheCollegeonMarketingoftheInstituteofManagementSciences,andpresentlyadirectoroftheAmericanMarketingAssociation.GeraldZaltmanisassociateprofessorofbehavioralscience,DepartmentofMarketing,GraduateSchoolofManagementandFacultyAssociateoftheCenterfortheInterdisciplinaryStudyofScienceandTechnologyatNorthwesternUniversity.HeholdsanMBAdegreefromTheUniversityofChicagoandaPhDinsociologyfromTheJohnsHopkinsUniversity.ProfessorZaltmanisauthorofMarketing:ContributionstromtheBehavioralSciences,co-editorofCreatingSocialChange(inpress).PerspectivesonSocialChange(inpress).andacontributortonumerousbooksandjournals.Hismajorresearchinterestsandwritingconcernthediffusionofinnovations,communication,socialchange.andthesociologyofscience.TheauthorswouldliketoexpresstheirappreciationtotheEducationalFoundationoftheAmericanAssociationofAdvertisingAgenciesfortheirsupportwhichpermittedactivitiesleadingtomanyoftheideasexpressedinthisarticle.
SocialMarketing:AnApproachtoPlannedSocialChange5mentation,performancemeasurement,andfeedbackcontrol.Therehasbeenashiftfromasalestoamarketingorientationinrecentyears.Asalesorientationconsidersthejobasoneoffindingcustomersforexistingproductsandconvincingthemtobuytheseproducts.ThissalesconceptisimplicitinTheSellingofthePresident1968,sinceoneisactuallynotdevelopinganew”product”forthejob,butrathertryingtosellagivenonewithasuggestionthatitissomewhat”newandimproved.”Themarketingconcept,ontheotherhand,callsformostoftheefforttobespentondiscoveringthewantsofatargetaudienceandthencreatingthegoodsandservicestosatisfythem.Thisviewseemsprivatelyandsociallymoreacceptable.Inprivateterms,thesellerrecognizesthatitiseasiertocreateproductsandservicesforexistingwantsthantotrytoalterwantsandattitudestowardexistingproducts.Insocialterms,itisheldthatthismarketingphilosophyrestoresconsumersovereigntyinthedeterminationofthesociety’sproductmixandtheuseofnationalresources.Inpractice,sinceatanytimetherearebothproductsinexistenceandnewproductsbeingborn,mostmarketingeffortsareamixtureofsellingandmarketing;thatis,achangestrategyandaresponsestrategy.Inbothcases,marketingmanagementisbecomingasophisticatedactiontechnologythatdrawsheavilyonthebehavioralsciencesforcluestosolvingproblemsofcommunicationandpersuasionrelatedtoinfluencingtheacceptabilityofcommercialproductsandservices.Inthehandsofitsbestpractitioners,marketingmanagementisappliedbehavioralscience.SocialMarketingAnincreasingnumberofnonbusinessinstitutionshavebeguntoexaminemarketinglogicasameanstofurtheringtheirinstitutionalgoalsandproducts.Marketingmenhaveadvisedchurchesonhowtoincreasemembership,charitiesonhowtoraisemoney,andartmuseumsandsymphoniesonhowtoattractmorepatrons.Inthesocialsphere,theAdvertisingCouncilofAmericahasconductedcampaignsforsocialobjectives,including”SmokeytheBear,””KeepAmericaBeautiful,””JointhePeaceCorps,””BuyBonds,”and”GotoCollege.”Infact,socialadvertisinghasbecomeanestablishedphenomenonontheAmericanscene.Sandagesays:True,(advertising’s)communicationfunctionhasbeenconfinedlargelytoinformingandpersuadingpeopleinrespecttoproductsandservices.Ontheotherhand,itcanbemadeequallyavailabletothosewhowishtoinformandpersuadepeopleinrespecttoacitybondissue,cleaningupcommunitycrime,the”logic”ofatheism,theneedsforbettereducationalfacilities,theabusivetacticsofgivenlawandenforcementofficers,oranyothersentimentheldbyanyindividualwhowishestopresentsuchsentimenttothepublic.”SocialadvertisinghasbecomesuchafeatureofAmericansocietythatitisnolongeraquestionofwhethertouseit,buthowtouseit.Ithasbeenverysuccessfulinsomecasesandconspicuouslyunsuccessfulinothers.Atfaulttoalargeextentisthetendencyofsocialcampaignerstoassignadvertisingtheprimary,ifnottheexclusive,roleinaccomplishingtheirsocialobjectives.Thisignoresthemarketingtruismthatagivenmarketingobjectiverequiresthecoordinationofthepromotionalmixwiththegoodsandservicesmixandwiththedistributionmix.Socialmarketingisamuchlargerideathansocialadvertisingandevensocialcommunication.Toemphasizethis,theauthorsdefinesocialmarketinginthefollowingway:Socialmarketingisthedesign,implementation,andcontrolofprogramscalculatedtoinfluencetheacceptabilityofsocialideasandinvolvingconsiderationsofproductplanning,pricing,communication,distribution,andmarketingresearch.Thus,itistheexplicituseofmarketingskillstohelptranslatepresentsocialactioneffortsintomoreeffectivelydesignedandcommunicatedprogramsthatelicitdesiredaudienceresponse.Inotherwords,marketingtechniquesarethebridgingmechanismsbetweenthesimplepossessionofknowledgeandthesociallyusefulimplementationofwhatknowledgeallows.TheRequisiteConditionsforEffectiveSocialMarketingSomecluesconcerningthedifferencebetweensocialadvertisingandsocialmarketingarecontainedinearlypapersbyLazarsfeldandMertonandbyWiebewhichattempttoexplainthelimitationsofsocialadvertising.”LazarsjeidandMerton’sAnalysisLazarsfeldandMertontookexceptionwiththeviewofmanypeoplethatmassmediacaneasilybeusedtocontrolpeople’sminds:”Itisourtentativejudgmentthatthesocialroleplayedbytheveryexistenceofthemassmediahasbeencommonlyoverestimated.”?Theybelievedthattheeffectivenessofmassmediaforpropagandapurposesdependedonthreeconditions,oneormoreofwhichislackinginmostpropagandasituations.Thefirst7C.H.Sandage,”UsingAdvertisingtoImplementtheConceptofFreedomofSpeech,”inTheRoleofAdvertising,C.H.SandageandV.Fryburger,eds.(Homewood,Ill.:RichardD.Irwin,Inc.,1960),pp.222-223.8PaulF.LazarsfeldandRobertK.Merton,”MassCommunication,PopularTaste,andOrganizedSocialAction,”inMassCommunications,WilliamSchramm,ed.(Urbana,Ill.:UniversityofIllinoisPress,1949),pp.459-480,andsamereferenceasfootnote1.9LazarsfeldandMerton,samereferenceasfootnote8,p.462.
6conditionisrealorpsychologicalmonopolizationbythemedia;thatis,aconditionmarkedbytheabsenceofcounterpropaganda.Thischaracterizesthetotalitarianstateandaccountsforthegreatereffectivenessoftheseregimesinmoldingpublicopinionthroughmassmedia.Itisfoundoccasionallyinfreesocietiesunderspecialcircumstances,suchasawartimeeffort.Forexample,KateSmith’seffectivenessinsellingwarbondsovertheradioduringWorldWarIIwaspartiallyduetothemarathonnatureoftheeventandthefactthateveryonebelievedinthecause;i.e.,therewasnocounterpropaganda.However,mostcampaignsinafreesocietyinpeacetimecompetewithsomanyothercausesandeverydaydistractionsthatthemonopolyconditionislacking,andthisconditionreducestheeffectivenessofsuchcampaigns.LazarsfeldandMertonsaidthesecondconditionrequiredforeffectivemasspropagandaiscanalization,thepresenceofanexistingattitudinalbaseforthefeelingsthatthesocialcommunicatorsarestrivingtoshape.Theyassertedthattypicalcommercialadvertisingiseffectivebecausethetaskisnotoneofinstillingbasicnewattitudesorcreatingsignificantlynewbehaviorpatterns,butrathercanalizingexistingattitudesandbehaviorinonedirectionoranother.Thus,theselleroftoothpastedoesnothavetosocializepersonsintonewdentalcarehabits,butratherintowhichbrandofafamiliaranddesiredproducttopurchase.Ifthepreexistingattitudesarepresent,thenpromotionalcampaignsaremoreeffective,sincecanalizationisalwaysaneasiertaskthansocialreconditioning.Theauthorsacceptthisideabutwouldaddthatmanybusinessmarketingsituationsalsoinvolvethetaskofreshapingbasicattitudesratherthancanalizingexistingones.Forexample,considerbusinesseffortstoinfluencefarmerstochangetimehonoredfarmingpractices,doctorstotryoutnewdrugs,andmalestodresswithmorefashionandflair.Canalizationisalwayseasier,buttheauthorswouldliketoemphasizethatbusinessmarketers,likesocialmarketers,oftentrytodiffusefundamentallynewproductsandserviceswhichrequiremajorattitudinalreorientations.LazarsfeldandMertoncallthethirdconditionsupplementationbywhichtheymeantheefforttofollowupmasscommunicationcampaignswithprogramsofface-to-facecontacts.IntryingtoexplainthesuccessoftherightistFatherCoughlinmovementinthethirties,LazarsfeldandMertonobserve:Thiscombinationofacentralsupplyofpropaganda(Coughlin’saddressesonanationwidenetwork),thecoordinateddistributionofnewspapersandpamphletsandlocallyorganizedface-to-facediscussionsamongrelativelysmallgroups-thiscomplexofreciprocalreinforcementbymassmediaandpersonalrelationsprovedspectacularlysuccessful.”?10LazarsfeldandMerton,samereferenceasfootnote8.JournalofMarketing,July,1971Thisapproachisstandardinmanyclosedsocietiesandorganizationsandsuggestsanotherkeydifferencebetweensocialadvertisingandsocialmarketing.Whereasasocialadvertisingapproachcontrivesonlytheeventofmassmediacommunicationandleavestheresponsetonaturalsocialprocesses,socialmarketingarrangesforastepdowncommunicationprocess.Themessageispassedonanddiscussedinmorefamiliarsurroundingstoincreaseitsmemorability,penetration,andactionconsequences.Thussupplementation,monopolization,andcanalizationarecriticalfactorsinfluencingtheeffectivenessofanysocialmarketingeffort.Wiebe’sAnalysisAnadditionalcontributionwasmadebyWiebeinhisattempttounderstandthedifferentialeffectivenessoffoursocialcampaigns.HHeexplainedtherelativeeffectivenessofthesecampaignsintermsoftheaudiencemember’sexperiencewithregardtofivefactors:1.TheForce.Theintensityoftheperson’smotivationtowardthegoalasacombinationofhispredispositionpriortothemessageandthestimulationofthemessage.2.TheDirection.Knowledgeofhoworwherethepersonmightgotoconsummatehismotivation.3.TheMechanism.Theexistenceofanagencythatenablesthepersontotranslatehismotivationintoaction.4.AdequacyandCompatibility.Theabilityandeffectivenessoftheagencyinperformingitstask.5.Distance.Theaudiencemember’sestimateoftheenergyandcostrequiredtoconsummatethemotivationinrelationtothereward.Toshowhowthesefactorsoperate,WiebefirstanalyzedtheKateSmithcompaigntosellbondsduringWorldWarII.Thiscampaignwaseminentlysuccessful,accordingtoWiebe,becauseofthepresenceofforce(patriotism),direction(buybonds),mechanism(banks,postoffices,telephoneorders),adequacyandcompatibility(somanycenterstopurchasethebonds),anddistance(easeofpurchase).Infact,extratelephonelineswereinstalledonthenightofthecampaignat134CBSstationstotakeordersduringherappeal.Theefforttobuybonds…wasliterallyreducedtothedistancebetweenthelistenerandhistelephone.Psychologicaldistancewasalsominimized.Thelistenerremainedinhisownhome.Therewerenonewpeopletomeet,nounfamiliarprocedures,noformstofillout,noexplanation,nowaiting…,12InthecaseofacampaigntorecruitCivilDefensevolunteers,manyofthesamefactorswerepresentexceptthatthesocialmechanismwasnot11Samereferenceasfootnote1.12Samereferenceasfootnote1,p.633.
SOCUlIMarketing:AnApproachtoPlannedSocialChange7preparedtohandlethelargevolumeofresponse,andthisreducedthecampaign’ssuccess.Teachers,manuals,equipment,andregistrationandadministrationprocedureswereinadequate,andmanyrespondingcitizenswereturnedawayanddisappointedaftertheywereledtobelievethattheirserviceswereurgentlyneeded.Thethirdcampaign,adocumentaryonjuveniledelinquency,didnotmeetwithmaximumsuccessbecauseoftheabsenceofamechanism.Insteadofbeingdirectedtoanexistingagency,peoplewereurgedtoformneighborhoodcouncilsthemselves.Thiscertainlytakesfarmoreeffortthansimplypickingupthephonetobuyawarbond,or”stoppingin”toregisteratthenearestCivilDefenseunit.ThefourthcampaignrevolvedaroundthegoaloftheKefauvercommitteehearingstoarousecitizensto”settheirhouseinorder.”Thiscampaignmetwithanotablelackofsuccess,however,becausecitizenswerenotdirectedtoanappropriatemechanismdespitethefactthatoneexistedinprincipleinthepoliticalpartyorganizations.Politicalpartyorganizationsapparentlyleftmuchtobedesiredintermsofavailabilityandcompatibility.Theskepticismprevalentatthetimeconcerningthechancesofanythingbeneficialhappeningasaresultofthehearingswasampleevidencethatconsiderablepsychologicaldistanceexistedbetweentheaudienceandthemechanismsforaction.TheSocialMarketingApproachTheLazarsfeldandMertonconditionsandtheWiebefactorsprovideausefulbackgroundforviewingtheconceptualframeworkusedbymarketingstrategists.Marketersviewthemarketingproblemasoneofdevelopingtherightproductbackedbytherightpromotionandputintherightplaceattherightprice.ThesekeyvariablesinthemarketingmixhavebeennamedthefourP’sbyMcCarthy.13Theauthorsshallexamineeachofthesevariables,designatedcontrolvariables,intermsofsomewellknownsocialissues.Product.Inbusinessmarketing,sellersstudytheneedsandwantsoftargetbuyersandattempttodesignproductsandservicesthatmeettheirdesires.Ifwell-designedandaffordable,theseproductswillbepurchased.Insocialmarketing,sellersalsohavetostudythetargetaudiencesanddesignappropriateproducts.Theymust”package”thesocialideainamannerwhichtheirtargetaudiencesfinddesirableandarewillingtopurchase.ThiscorrespondstoWiebe’sideaofamechanism.Productdesignistypicallymorechallenginginthesocialareathanitisinthebusinessarea.Considertheproblemofmarketing”saferdriving.”Thesocialobjectiveistocreatesaferdrivinghabitsand13E.JeromeMcCarthy,BasicMarketing:AManagerialApproach,ThirdEdition(Homewood,Ill.:RichardD.Irwin,Inc.,1968),pp.31-33.attitudesinthepopulation.Thereisnooneproductthatcanaccomplishthis.Variousproductshavetobedesignedthatwillmakepartialcontributionstothesocialobjective.Apubliceducationmediacampaignprovidingtipsonsafedrivingisonesuchproduct;theofferingof”defensivedrivingcourses”isanother;thecreationofinsurancepolicieswhichreducepremiumsforsaferdriversisstillanotherproduct.Ingeneral,thesocialmarketerremainsawareofthecoreproduct(saferdriving)andtriestocreatevarioustangibleproductsandserviceswhichare”buyable”andwhichadvancethesocialobjective.Identicalreasoningisrequiredbythosewhomarketaltruisticcauses(e.g.,charitygiving,blooddonation),personalhealthcauses(e.g.,nonsmoking,betternutrition),andsocialbettermentcauses(e.g.,civilrights,improvedhousing,betterenvironment).Ineachcase,thesocialmarketermustdefinethechangesought,whichmaybeachangeinvalues,beliefs,affects,behavior,orsomemixture.Hemustmeaningfullysegmentthetargetmarkets.Hemustdesignsocialproductsforeachmarketwhichare”buyable,”andwhichinstrumentallyservethesocialcause.Insomesocialcauses,themostdifficultproblemwillbetoinnovateappropriateproducts;inothercasesitwillbetomotivatepurchase.Promotion.Themarketingman’ssecondcontrolvariableispromotion.Itisthecommunicationpersuasionstrategyandtacticsthatwillmaketheproductfamiliar,acceptable,andevendesirabletotheaudience.Wiebe’scounterparttopromotionis”force.”Thesocialcampaignstrategistwilltendtothinkofthisasmassmediacommunication,butpromotionisactuallyamuchlargeridea.Tothemarketingman,promotionincludesthefollowingmajoractivities:Advertising:Anypaidformofnonpersonalpresentationandpromotionofproducts,services,orideasbyanidentifiedsponsor.PersonalSelling:Anypaidformofpersonalpresentationandpromotionofproducts,service,orideasbyanidentifiedsponsor.Publicity:Anyunpaidformofnonpersonalpresentationandpromotionofproducts,services,orideaswherethesponsorisunidentified.SalesPromotion:Miscellaneouspaidforms(specialprograms,incentives,materials,andevents)designedtostimulateaudienceinterestandacceptanceofaproduct.Eachofthesepromotionaltoolsinvolvescomplexissuesinstrategyandtactics.Withrespecttoadvertising,themarketerhastodeterminethesizeofthetotaladvertisingbudget,thechoiceofappeals,thedevelopmentofattention-gettingcopy,theselectionofeffectiveandefficientmedia,theschedulingoftheadvertisinginputs,andthemeasurementofoverallandsegment-levelresults.Withrespecttopersonalselling,themarketermustdeterminethesizeofthetotalsalesforce,thede-
8velopmentofsalesterritoryboundariesandassignments,thedevelopmentofpersonalpresentationstrategies,thedegreeandtypeofsalesforcemotivationandsupervision,andtheevaluationofsalesforceeffectiveness.Publicitynecessitatesarrangingforsignificantnewsabouttheproducttoappearinvariousmedia.Salespromotioncallsfordevelopingspecialdisplay,premiums,programs,andeventsthatmightbeusefulinstimulatinginterestoraction.Eachoftheseactivitiesisaspecialtyinwhichtheexpertshaveachievedsophisticatedlevelsofknowledgeandtechniques.Thisisespeciallyapparentwhenoneexaminessocialcampaignsdevelopedbyamateurswheretheappealsandcopyseemverynaive.Evenbehavioralscienceconsultantstosocialcampaignorganizationsoftenfailtomakeamaximumcontributionbecauseoftheirinabilityorreluctancetoviewtheissueinbroadmarketingtermsinsteadofinstrictlysocialorethicalterms.RecentlyNathanielMartincriticizedtheIndiangovernmentforfailingtohandlefamilyplanningasamarketingproblem.Sellingbirthcontrolisasmuchamarketingjobassellinganyotherconsumerproduct.Andwherenomanufacturerwouldcontemplatedevelopingandintroducinganewproductwithoutathoroughunderstandingofthevariablesofthemarket,plannersinthehighestcirclesofIndiangovernmenthaveblithelygoneaheadwithoutunderstandingthatmarketingprinciplesmustdeterminethecharacterofanycampaignofvoluntarycontrol.TheIndianshavedoneonlythepoorestresearch.Theyhavemismanageddistributionofcontraceptivedevices.Theyhaveignoredtheimportanceof”customerservice.”Theyhaveproceededwithgrosslyinadequateundertrainedstaffs;theyhavebeenblindtotheimportanceofpromotionandadvertlsing.wThisisnottodenythattheIndiangovernmenthasundertakensomeinnovativepromotionalapproaches.Referralfeesarepaidtosalesmen,barbers,andotherswhobringinconsentingmalesforsterilization.Theconsentingmaleisgivenatransistorradioorasmallpaymenttocoverhiscostsofbeingabsentfromwork.Womenhavebeenofferedgiftsforconsentingtouseintrauterinecontraceptivedevices.ButMartinfeelsthatthetotalprogramlacksthequalitiesofanorganized,wellplanned,andcontinuousmarketingeffort.l514NathanielA.Martin,”TheOutlandishIdea:HowaMarketingManWouldSaveIndia,”Marketing/Communications,Vol.297(March,1968),pp.54-60.15Fortwoanalysesofthemarketingissuesandopportunitiesinthefamilyplanningissue,seeJulianL.Simon,”AHugeMarketingResearchTask-BirthControl,”JournalofMarketingResearch,Vol.5(February,1968),pp.21-27;andGlenL.Urban,”IdeasonaDecision-InformationSystemforFamilyPlanning,”IndustrialManagementReview,Vol.10(Spring,1969),pp.45-61.JournalofMarketing,July,1971AnexampleofcarefulpromotionalplanningforasocialobjectiveisfoundintheAmericanCancerSocietyeffortstoraisemoneyforcancerresearch.Intheirbrochuredirectedtolocalunits,theyattempttoeducatethevolunteerandprofessionalchaptersonthehandlingofnewspapers,pictures,companypublications,radioandtelevision,movies,specialevents,andcontroversialarguments.Forexample,intermsofspecialevents:DramaticspecialeventsattractattentiontotheAmericanCancerSociety.Theybringcolor,excitement,andglamourtotheprogram.Wellplanned,theywillgetexcellentcoverageinnewspapers,onradioandTV,andinnewsreels….ALights-on-Drive,aone-afternoonorone-nightHouse-to-Houseprogramhavesuchdramaticappealthattheystirexcitementandenthusiasm…keepinmindthevalueofburstsofsoundsuchasfiresirenssounding,loud-speakertrucks,fifeanddrumcorps….Amostusefulspecialeventistheringingofchurchbellstoaddasolemn,dedicatednotetothelaunchingofadriveoreducationproject.ThisshouldbeorganizedonaDivisionorcommunitybasis,andthechurchbellringingmaybethesignaltobeginaHouseto-Housecanvass.Rehearsalsofbellringing,communityleaderstuggingatropes,offergoodpicturepossibilities.t”Somereadersmightbecriticalofthisapproachtoaworthwhilesocialobjective,buttwothingsshouldbementioned.Thefirstisthatthisshouldnotbeidentifiedasthemarketingapproachtosocialobjectives.Manypersonsmistakenlyassumethatmarketingmeanshardselling.Thisisonlyaparticularstyleofmarketing,andithasitscriticsbothinsideandoutsidetheprofession.Therearemanyfirmsthatmarkettheirproductswithtasteandsensitivity;examplesincludeXerox,ContainerCorporation,andHallmark.Itisimportanttorecognizethatthisisnotnonmarketingbutratherastyleofmarketingthatwaschoseninthebeliefofitsgreatereffectivenessinaccomplishingthegoalsoftheorganization.Second,theissueisnotwhetheraparticularapproachsuitsone’spersonaltaste,butwhetheritworks.Ifa”hard”marketingstyleraisessubstantiallymoremoneyforcancerresearchthana”soft”marketingstyle,itmustberespectedbythosewhothinkcancerresearchismoreimportantthanpersonalaesthetics.Place.Thethirdelementofthemarketingapproachtosocialcampaignscallsforprovidingadequateandcompatibledistributionandresponsechannels.Motivatedpersonsshouldknowwheretheproductcanbeobtained.PlaceisequivalenttotwoofWiebe’sfiveconditionsforaneffectivemasscommunicationcampaign(direction,andadequacyandcompatibility).Thepoorresultsofmanysocial16PublicInformationGuide(NewYork:AmericanCancerSociety,Inc.,1965),p.19.
SocialMarketing:AnApproachtoPlannedSocialChange9campaignscanbeattributedinparttotheirfailuretosuggestclearactionoutletsforthosemotivatedtoacquiretheproduct.Thecurrentcampaigntointerestpeopleinthepollutionproblemmaysufferfromthisdefect.Itissucceedinginmakingeveryonenotonlyawareofenvironmentalpollutionbutalsofearfulofit.Peoplewanttodosomethingaboutit.Butforthemostparttheycannotactbecausethereisnotaclearproductto”buy”(suchasapetitiontosign,anelectioninwhichtochooseanantipollutioncandidate,orapendingpieceofnationallegislation).Nordoestheaveragepersonhaveaclearpictureofthealternativechannelsofactionforexpressinghisinterestintheissue.Therearesomanyadhocorganizationsworkingwithoutcoordinationandattimeswithcross-purpose,thattheaveragepersonislikelyto”tuneout”fromfurthermessagesbecauseofpersonalfrustration.Saturationcampaignsunaccompaniedbytheprovisionofadequateresponsechannelsmayresultin”interestoverkill.”Theimportanceofplacehasbeenrecognizedinseveralcampaigns.ThemostnotableexampleistheKateSmithbond-sellingcampaignanditsimaginativeestablishmentoftelephoneorderchannelsduringthebroadcast.Strategistsofanticigarettecampaignshaverecognizedtheneedforactionchannelsbysettingupsmoker’sclinicsinmanylargecities.Theycouldevengofurtherandprovidetelephoneadviceandevensocialcallsiftheeconomicswouldjustifytheseadditionalchannels.Anadvertisingagencyisplanningacampaigncalled”PickYourIssue”inwhichseveraldifferentsocialissueswouldbeindividuallyfeatured.Thepointwouldbemadethatbecausethebusycitizendoesnothavetimetobecomeinvolvedinallissues,thisshouldnotbeanexcusetoremainuninvolvedinanyissues.Thegoodcitizenshould”pickanissue.”Eachissueadvertisementwillcontaininformationontheorganizationsactiveinthatareaandinformthecitizenaboutwheretowriteforfurtherinformation.Thus,placemeansarrangingforaccessibleoutletswhichpermitthetranslationofmotivationsintoactions.Planninginthisareaentailsselectingordevelopingappropriateoutlets,decidingontheirnumber,averagesize,andlocations,andgivingthempropermotivationtoperformtheirpartofthejob.Price.Thefinalcontrolvariablethatmustbeplannedisprice.Pricerepresentsthecoststhatthebuyermustacceptinordertoobtaintheproduct.ItresemblesWiebe’sconceptofdistanceandincorporatessomeaspectsofadequacyandcompatibility.Priceincludesmoneycosts,opportunitycosts,energycosts,andpsychiccosts.Thus,thecosttopersonsaskedtoappearforimmunizationshotsincludesanypossiblemoneycharge,anyopportunitiesforegone,theexpenditureofenergy,andthepsychologicalconcernsarousedbyinoculation.Thecostofgrvmgupsmokingislargelypsychological,sincethereisactuallyafinancialsavinginbreakingthehabit.Thecostofusingseatbeltsisthechargeforbuyingthem,theefforttolockandunlockthem,andthepsychologicalcostofnotbeingcompletelysureoneisbetteroffinanaccidentwearingthemornotwearingthem.Thefunctioningofthisconceptcanalsobeillustratedintermsofaninterestingphenomenoninhealthcareserviceswheremanypoorpatientsprefertopatronizeunlicensedpractitionersandpayafeeinsteadofgoingtothefreehospital.InCaracas,Venezuela,forexample,althoughthereisafreehospitalfortheindigent,manyofthempatronizeprivateclinicswhichcostthem20bolivaresforconsultation.Why?Becausewhilethereisnochargeatthefreehospital,thereisasubstantialcosttothepatientintermsofenergyandpsychologicalabuse.Whenapatientarrivesatthehospital,hehastowaittoseeasocialworkerfirst.Whenheisfinallyinterviewed,thesocialworkerasksmanyquestionsabouthisincometodeterminewhetherheisreallyindigent.Thenheseesanumberofotherhospitalstaffmembersforvarioustests,andagainisaskedabouthisincome.Finally,heseesthedoctorwhomightdiscoverthathereallyneedstoseeaspecialistwhowillnotbeavailableforseveralweeks.Throughouttheexperience,thepersonismadetofeelinferiorandanuisance.Therefore,itisnotsurprisingthathewishestoavoidtheseenergyandpsychologicalcostsevenifitmeanspayingfortheservices.Butevenmonetarychargesmayplayausefulroleinleadingthepoorbacktofreehospitalservices.Inprivatecorrespondence,asocialpsychologistsuggested:Itisasurprisingdiscoverythatevenfreemedicalcarepresentsamarketingproblem.Maybeweshouldapplydissonancetheoryandintroducesuchmedicalcareatahighpricetomakeitlookmoredesirable.Thenletusapplyacents-offspecial.introductoryoffertomaketheserviceattractive.Themarketingman’sapproachtopricingthesocialproductisbasedontheassumptionthatmembersofatargetaudienceperformacost-benefitanalysiswhenconsideringtheinvestmentofmoney,time,orenergyintheissue.Theysomehowprocessthemajorbenefitsandcomparethemtothemajorcosts,andthestrengthoftheirmotivationtoactisdirectlyrelatedtothemagnitudeoftheexcessbenefit.Thistypeofconceptualizationofbehaviorisfoundnotonlyintheeconomist’smodelofeconomicman,butalsoinbehavioristictheorywithitsemphasisonrewardsandcosts,inGestalttheorywithitsemphasisonpositiveandnegativevalences,andinmanagementtheorywithitsemphasisonincentivesandconstraints.Themarketer’sapproachtosellingasocialproductistoconsiderhowtherewardsforbuyingtheproductcanbeincreasedrelativetothecosts,orthecostsreducedrelative
10JournalofMarketing,Jul’)’,1971PLANNINGVARIABLESMARKETSMiscellaneoustargetmarketsSecondarytargetmarketPrimarytargetmarketCHANNELSPaidagentsMassandspecializedmediaProductPlacePromotionPrice1.Moneycosts2.Opportunitycosts3.Energycosts4.Psychiccosts1.ChanneltypesVoluntarygroupsTertiary2.NumberI—I-t-jll’landorganizationsI-+-H’1target3.Sizemarket4.Locations5.Compatibility1.Advertising2.Personalselling3.Publicity4.Salespromotion1.Coreproduct2.TangibleproductsResearchPlanningUnitUnitCHANGEAGENCYENVIRONMENT1.Economic2.Political3.TechnologicalI–~4.Cultural5.CompetitiveFIGURE1.Socialmarketingplanningsystem.totherewards,ortryingtofindamixofproduct,promotion,place,andpricethatwillsimultaneouslyincreasetherewardsandreducethecosts.Themainpointisthatsocialmarketingrequiresthatcarefulthoughtbegiventothemannerinwhichmanageable,desirable,gratifying,andconvenientsolutionstoaperceivedneedorproblemarepresentedtoitspotentialbuyers.TheSocialMarketingPlanningProcessThe”fourP’s”ofmarketingmanagementareintegratedinanadministrativeprocessframeworkinFigure1.Continuousinformationiscollectedfromtheenvironmentbythechangeagency.Plansandmessagesarecreatedandsentthroughchannelstoaudiences,andtheresultsaremonitoredbythechangeagency.Thechangeagencyoperatesaresearchunitandaplanningunit.Theresearchunitcollectsseveraltypesofinformation.Itmonitorstheenvironment–economic,political,technological,cultural,andcompetitiveinfluences-forimportantdevelopmentsaffectingitssocialpoliciesandobjectives.Forexample,afamilyplanningagencywouldmonitoreconomic-demographicdevelopments(incomeandpopulationtrends),politicaldevelopments(liberalizationofbirthcontrolinformation),technologicaldevelop-ments(newbirthcontroltechniquesanddevices),culturaldevelopments(attitudinalchangestowardbirthcontrol),andcompetitivedevelopments(actionsofsimilarandcompetinggroups).Theresearchunitalsocollectsinformationonthepasteffectivenessofvariousprogramsaswellasinformationonaudienceattitudes,desires,andbehavior.Thechangeagent’splanningunitformulatesshort-andlong-rangesocialmarketingplansonthebasisofthisinformation.Forexample,thefamilyplanningorganizationcarefullyconsiderstheroleofdifferentproducts,promotions,places,andprices.Itwouldidentifythemajorchannelsofcommunicationanddistribution,suchasmassorspecializedmedia,paidagents,andvolunteergroups.Itwoulddifferentiatetheprogramsintendedforitsprimarytargetmarket(largeandlow-incomefamilies),secondarytargetmarket(otherchildbearingfamilies),tertiarytargetmarket(sourcesoffundsandadditionalvolunteerefforts),andmiscellaneoustargetmarkets(politiciansandchurchgroups).Finally,itwouldcontinuouslygathereffectivenessmeasuresontheseprogramsforrecyclingitsplanning.Thisapproachrepresentsanapplicationofbusinessmarketingprinciplestotheproblemofmarketingsocialchange.Itisalreadymanifestinsomeofthelargersocialchangeagencies.Forexample,
SocialMarketing:AnApproachtoPlannedSocialChange11i.Massmediaadvertisingcampaignsz,specraipresentationstoexecutivesBUSiNESSFIRMSi.GroupdiscountsSERVICEORGANIZATrONS2.Fundraisingi.MonthlyDDCbulletini.LocaladvertisingNATIONAL2.FilmLOCAL2.DirectmailSAFETY3.ConsumerleafletsSAFETY3.DashboardstickersDRIVERSCOUNCIL4.TrainingplansforplantsCOUNCILS4.Bring-a-frienddlsoount5.Tie-insalesLDirectrecruit-SCHOOLSrnent2.FlyerswhichchildrenbringhometotheirparentsPOLICEANDCOURTSLMassmediaadvertisingcampaigns2.selectivemediaadvertisingcampaigns3.Salespromotion4.PublicityFIGURE2.Marketingchannelsandtools:Defensivedrivingcourse.considertheworkoftheNationalSafetyCouncil.Itsstaffincludesanadvertisingmanager,asalespromotionmanagement,anAdvertisingCouncilofAmericacoordinator,aresearchdirector,andaprogramdirector.Oneofitsproductsisadefensivedrivingcourse.Figure2showsthevariouschannelsthroughwhichthiscourseismarketedalongwiththepromotionaltoolsituses.TheNationalSafetyCouncilreachespotentialprospectsthroughbusinessfirms,serviceorganizations,schools,andthepoliceandcourtsystem.Forthe1970s,theNationalSafetyCouncilhasadopted…afourpointmarketingprogram….Oneofthefirstobjectivesistoincreasethesaleseffectivenessofourexisting150stateandlocalsafetycouncilcooperatingagencies….Thesecondpartoftheprogramistocreate500newtrainingagenciesincommunitiesnotnowservedbysafetycouncils….AthirdpartofthemarketingprogramwillbeaimedatsellingbigindustryonadoptingDDCasatrainingcourseforallemployeesorselectedcategoriesofemployeesinplant-runtrainingprograms….Thefourthpartofthemarketingplandealswithanationwidepromotionaleffortbuiltaroundaseriesofcommunityspecial-emphasiscampaignsrunningfromFebruary1throughMemorialDayeachyearofthedecade.l”Thisexampleillustratesthepossibilitiesofthemarketingapproachforfurtheringsocialcauses.TheNationalSafetyCouncilandseveralothersocialagencieshavegraduatedfromoccasionalcam-17ChrisImhoff,”DDC’sDecisiveDecade,”TrafficSafetyMagazine,Vol.69(December,1969),pp.20and36.paignorganizationstofull-timemarketingorganizationswhichgothroughcyclesofinformationgathering,planning,productdevelopment,measuring,andreprogramming.SocialImplicationsofSocialMarketingTheauthorsbelievethatspecificsocialcausescouldbenefitfrommarketingthinkingandplanning.Problemsofpollutioncontrol,masstransit,privateeducation,drugabuse,andpublicmedicineareinneedofinnovativesolutionsandapproachesforgainingpublicattentionandsupport.Marketingmenbytheirtrainingarefinelyattunedtomarketneeds,productdevelopment,pricingandchannelissues,andmasscommunicationandpromotiontechniques,allofwhicharecriticalinthesocialarea.Atthesametime,socialmarketingissufficientlydistinctfrombusinessmarketingtorequirefreshthinkingandnewapproaches.Socialmarketingtypicallyhastodealwiththemarket’scorebeliefsandvalues,whereasbusinessmarketingoftendealswithsuperficialpreferencesandopinions.Socialmarketingmustsearchharderformeaningfulquidproquostogainacceptanceoradoptionofitsproducts.Socialmarketinghastoworkwithchannelsystemsthatarelesswell-definedandlesspecuniarilymotivated.Onlythroughapplyingmarketingconceptsandtoolstoalargenumberofcaseswillthepowersandlimitsofthesocialmarketingapproachbelearned.Inaddition,thereisthedefinitepossibilitythattheovertmarketingofsocialobjectiveswillberesentedandresisted.Therewillbechargesthatitis”manipulative,”andconsequentlycontributes
12tobringingthesocietyclosertoOrwell’s1984.Therewillbechargesthatevenifnotmanipulative,socialmarketingwillincreasetheamountof”promotionalnoise”inthesociety,whichisfounddistastefulbothbecauseitemphasizes”trivialdifferences”andbecauseitis”noise.”Finally,socialmarketingwillbeaccusedofincreasingthecostsofpromotingsocialcausesbeyondthepointofanetgaineithertothespecificcauseorthesocietyasawhole.Inthecharitiesindustry,professionalmarketingincreasestheabsolutecostofraisingmoney,butitusuallysucceedsinraisingmoremoneyafterthesecostsaretakenintoaccount.However,whenoneconsiderstheentirepicture,itispossiblethatthetotalamountdonatedtocharitiesmaynotincreasebythesameamountastheprofessionalmarketingcosts.Theauthorsareconcernedwiththesepossibledysfunctionalconsequences,andtheymustobviouslybesubtractedfromthepotentialbenefitsthatsocialmarketingmightproduce.Sincesocialmarketingisjustemerging,thoseconcernedareencouragedtomonitoritcloselyinthesamedispassionatespiritthatbusinessmarketershavesoablyanalyzedanddocumentedthemanymanifestationsofbusinessmarketingpracticeovertheyears.SummaryThisarticleconsideredtheapplicabilityofmarketingconceptstotheproblemofpromotingsocialcauses.Socialmarketingwasdefinedasthedesign,implementation,andcontrolofprogramscalculatedtoinfluencetheacceptabilityofsocialideasandinvolvingconsiderationsofproductplanning,pric-..JournalofMarketing,July,1971ing,communication,distribution,andmarketingresearch.Toooften,socialadvertisingratherthansocialmarketingispracticedbysocialcampaigners.LazarsfeldandMertonattributedthefailureofmanysocialadvertisingcampaignstothefrequentabsenceofconditionsofmonopolization,canalization,andsupplementationinthesocialarena.Wiebe,inhisexaminationoffourcampaigns,concludedthatacampaign’seffectivenessdependedonthepresenceofadequateforce,direction,anadequateandcompatiblesocialmechanism,anddistance.Tothemarketer,thesuccessofthecampaigndependsontheproperdevelopmentofproduct,promotion,place,andpriceconsiderations.Theseconceptsweredefinedandwereshowntohaveapplicabilitytosocialcauses.Thesocialmarketingprocesscallsformarketingresearchandthesubsequentdevelopmentofawell-conceivedproductandappealsmovingthroughmassandspecializedcommunicationmediaandthroughpaidagentsandvoluntarygroupstoreachtargetedaudiences.Themarketingstylemaybehardorsoft,dependingonwhichisdeemedmosteffectiveinaccomplishingthesocialobjectives.Amarketingplanningapproachdoesnotguaranteethatthesocialobjectiveswillbeachieved,orthatthecostswillbeacceptable.Yetsocialmarketingappearstorepresentabridgingmechanismwhichlinksthebehavioralscientist’sknowledgeofhumanbehaviorwiththesociallyusefulimplementationofwhatthatknowledgeallows.Itoffersausefulframeworkforeffectivesocialplanningatatimewhensocialissueshavebecomemorerelevantandcritical…MARKETINGMEMOTheMarketingConceptandTechnology•…..Itisamistaketothinkoftechnologyasentirelyautonomous,althoughithassecuredforitselfagreatdealofautonomy.Anditisamistaketothinkthatthetechnologicalsystemisself-justifyinginitsownterms.Thepresentecologicalcrisisandfundamentalrethinkingoftechnology’sroleinthesocietyofthefutureistheprimafacieillustrationofthispoint.Wearegoingtoabandonmanytechnologicaldevelopmentseventhoug
Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers
Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.
Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS
Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?
Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.
We write plagiarism Free Content
Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.
Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.