What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of collecting race and crime statistics?
Instructions:
1) Begin by reading section 2.1 titled “Should Race and Ethnicity Categories be Excluded from Crime Statistics” from the assigned reading for WEEK 3 (Chapter 2, Gabbidon).
2) Utilize the arguments presented in this chapter, combined with your comprehension of challenges of accurately measuring race and ethnicity in week 2, to respond to the following questions:
Should the United States reevaluate its practice of collecting race and crime statistics? Provide a comprehensive explanation for your stance, supporting it with reasoning.
What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of collecting race and crime statistics? Offer a detailed analysis of both sides, substantiating your points with logical explanations.
Reminders: Ensure that your reflection paper adheres to the following guidelines:
Maintain a word count ranging from 350 to 700 words.
Type your paper in double-spaced format.
Submit your completed assignment in either .doc, .docx, or .pdf file formats
For a comprehensive understanding of the assignment’s requirements, refer to the rubric Download rubricoutlining the key components necessary for successful completion.
Requirements: 400-700 words limit
Extent of Crime and VictimizationGabbidon& Greene Chapter 1 Chapter 2
Learning Objectives (1) Understand arrest and victimization trends in the United States(2) Examine what arrest and victimization trends do and do not tell us about race and crime(3) Examine trends in human trafficking, homicide, and hate crime incidents (4) Assess the policy implications of historical and contemporary race, crime, and victimization trends. 2
Where do we get information about crime and victimization? 3
Extent of Crime and Victimization•The Bureau of Justice Statistics is the primary statistical agency in the U.S. Department of Justice.•Some of the research that relies on crime statistics leads to misperceptions about race and crime.•Although crime statistics were not initially designed to label certain groups of people as criminals, this is exactly what has occurred.4
History of Crime and Victimization Statistics in the United States•The history of crime statistics in the United States dates back to the 19th century•Several state legislatures mandated the collection of statistics on crime and criminals. •Judicial statistics•Prison statistics•At the federal level, crime statistics were reported by the U.S. Census Bureau through 1800’s.•Beginningin1850,collecteddataforconvictedpersonsincludedsex,age,nativity,andcoloroftheconvictedperson.5
The Uniform Crime Reporting Program•In 1930, the FBI began collecting data from police departments•Seven offenses comprised the crime index:•Murder/nonnegligent manslaughter•Forcible rape•Robbery•Aggravated assault•Burglary•Larceny/theft•Motor vehicle theft•In 1979, arson was added6
The Uniform Crime Reporting Program, cont.•In 1980, the UCR renamed arrest race categories to include American Indian or Alaskan Native, and Asian or Pacific Islander•During the 1980s, efforts to modernize the UCR program resulted in the implementation of the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS)7
Victimization Surveys•In 1972, the Law Enforcement Assistance Administration implemented the NCVS (National Crime Victimization Survey)•The survey includes collected information from a representative sample of households on victims of nonfatal violent and property crimes in the United States•Early surveys included approximately 100,000 persons and 50,000 households in 26 cities. 8
Limitations of the Statistics 9
Limitations of Arrest and Victimization Data•Crime statistics are unreliable because they cannot tell us how much crime takes place, how many persons were arrested, or how many crime victims there are•Definition of racial categories is limited•Racial categories do not account for ethnic differences within groups (e.g., Jamaican, Haitian, and AfricanamongthosewhoareBlack, orMexican, Dominican, Puerto Rican, among those who are Latino) 10
Defining Racial Categories•Despite efforts to improve racial/ethnic categories, they are fatally flawed for two reasons•They are unable to capture intraracial and intraethnicheterogeneity•How racial categories and ethnicity are determined is questionable and often inaccurate11
Variations in Reporting and Recording•For various reasons, citizens do not report, and police do not record, all crimes•Police selectively enforce the law, which might contribute to variations by race•Variations in crime categories •Recording only the most serious crimes is also problematic for the UCR12
Utilization of Population, Crime,Arrest, and Victimization Estimates•Estimations are an important part of the methodology and findings reported in both the UCR and NCVS•The UCR uses population estimates to calculate the crime and arrest rates•The NCVS relies on a sample of the population to estimate crime victimizations•Though victimization statistics have their limitations, they have value for examining patterns and trends by race/ethnic categories13
Arrest Trends•The UCR provide crime data for eight offenses (four violent crimes against the person and four property crimes)•In 2016, the violent crime rate was much lower than the property crime rate•Compared to earlier decades, the number of arrests have trended downward in all racial categories•Between 2012 and 2016, Whites and Blacks were mostly arrested for drug violations14
Victimization Trends15
Victimization Trends•The NCVS publishes other reports that present victimization trends and analyses of victimization within racial groups•Unlike the UCR, since 1977, the NCVS has included a separate category for “Hispanic/Latino” and, more recently, “Two or More Races” •Homicide victimizations are reported annually in the UCR Supplementary Homicide Reports and have been published in the NCVS as well16
Victimization Trends17
Domestic Violence and Interpersonal Violence Victimization•Domestic violence victimization (DVV) refers to both fatal and nonfatal incidents that take place in families, between intimate partners, or with friends and acquaintances•Offenses occur regardless of one’s race, age, or class•2003–2012 rates of domestic violence are highest for persons between 18 and 24 years old18
Race and Human Trafficking•Human trafficking is defined as the recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or other services and for coercive commercial sex acts•According to the FBI’s Human Trafficking Reporting System (HTRS), in 2016, there were 916 adults arrested for human trafficking, with Whites (626) and Blacks (251) predominating the arrests19
Homicide Victimizations•Homicide is one of the more accurately measured offenses•Arrest trends for murder/nonnegligent manslaughter can be analyzed by type of jurisdiction where the arrest occurred•Between 2012 and 2015, Blacks arrested for murder outnumbered Whites arrested in cities•In metropolitan and nonmetropolitan counties and suburban areas, the number of White persons arrested for murder outnumbered those who are Black.20
Hate Crime Trends•The terms hate or bias crimes refer to offenses committed against individuals because of their race, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or disability•Lynching was one of the earliest types of hate crimes, though it was not always considered a criminal act•As long as hate/bias statistics have been available, most offenses reported are motivated by anti-Black bias21
Hate Crime Trends•Hate crime is more likely than street crime to involve crimes against the person than crimes against property•Hate crime is also more likely to be interracial; the race of most known offenders is White•BJS study found that young offenders were responsible for most hate crimes22
Conclusion•For more than 70 years, the UCR has been the primary source of crime statistics•For over 30 years, the NCVS has provided victimization data•While the data provide information about race and crime, racial categorization in each data set is problematic•Although hate/bias crimes have occurred for several hundred years, the collection of hate crime statistics is rather recent23
Conclusion, cont.•Crime statistics tell us either nothing (UCR) or little (NCVS) about the effects of class and crime. •Fixation on violent crimes has contributed to the racialization of crime.•Hate crimes reveal a dimension of race and crime that is often ignored•Blacks are more likely to be the victims of bias crimes than any other group24
Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers
Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.
Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS
Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?
Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.
We write plagiarism Free Content
Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.
Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.
