Business Ethics Case Study 10.4 Esssay Questions Content Read Case 10.4 (The Housing Allowance) and answer the questions at the end of the case. Please respond in full detailed senten
Business Ethics
Case Study 10.4
Esssay Questions Content
Read Case 10.4 (The Housing Allowance) and answer the questions at the end of the case. Please respond in full detailed sentences. Please pay attention to your grammar, in-text citations, and references.
Case 10.4. The Housing Allowance
Wilson Mutambara grew up in the slums outside Stanley, capital of the sub-Saharan African country of Rambia.* Through talent, hard work, and luck he made it through secondary school and won a scholarship to study in the United States. He eventually received an MBA and went to work for NewCom, a cellular telephone service. After three years in the company’s Atlanta office, Wilson was given an opportunity to return to Rambia, where NewCom was setting up a local cellular service. Eager to be home, Wilson Mutambara couldn’t say yes fast enough.
NewCom provides its employees in Rambia with a monthly allowance of up to $2,000 for rent, utilities, and servants. By Western standards, most of the housing in Stanley is poor quality, and many of its neighborhoods are unsafe. By providing the allowance, NewCom’s intention is to see that its employees live in areas that are safe and convenient and that they live in a style that is appropriate to the company’s image.
To claim their housing allowance, NewCom’s employees in Rambia are supposed to turn in receipts, and every month Wilson Mutambara turned in an itemized statement for $2,000 from his landlord. Nobody at NewCom thought it was unusual that Wilson never entertained his coworkers at home. After all, he worked long hours and traveled frequently on business. However, after Wilson had been in Rambia for about fifteen months, one of his coworkers, Dale Garman, was chatting with a Rambian customer, who referred in passing to Wilson as a person living in Old Town. Garman knew Old Town was one of the slums outside Stanley, but he kept his surprise to himself and decided not to mention this information to anyone else until he could independently confirm it. This wasn’t difficult for him to do. Wilson was indeed living in Old Town in the home of some relatives. The house itself couldn’t have rented for more than $300, even if Wilson had the whole place to himself, which he clearly didn’t. Dale reported what he had learned to Wilson’s supervisor, Barbara Weston.
When Weston confronted him about the matter, Wilson admitted that the place did rent for a “little less” than $2,000, but he vigorously defended his action this way: “Every other NewCom employee in Rambia receives $2,000 a month. If I live economically, why should I be penalized? I should receive the same as everyone else.” In response, Weston pointed out that NewCom wanted to guarantee that its employees had safe, high-quality housing that was in keeping with the image that the company wanted to project. Wilson’s housing arrangements were “unseemly,” she said, and not in keeping with his professional standing. Moreover, they reflected poorly on the company. To this, Wilson Mutambara retorted: “I’m not just a NewCom employee; I’m also a Rambian. It’s not unsafe for me to live in this neighborhood, and it’s insulting to be told that the area I grew up in is ‘unseemly’ or inappropriate for a company employee.”
Barbara Weston pointed out that the monthly receipts he submitted had been falsified. “Yes,” he admitted, “but that’s common practice in Rambia. Nobody thinks twice about it.” However, she pressed the point, arguing that he had a duty to NewCom, which he had violated. As the discussion continued, Mutambara became less confident and more and more distraught. Finally, on the verge of tears, he pleaded, “Barbara, you just don’t understand what’s expected of me as a Rambian or the pressure I’m under. I save every penny I have to pay school fees for eight nieces and nephews. I owe it to my family to try to give those children the same chance I had. My relatives would never understand my living in a big house instead of helping them. I’m just doing what I have to do.”
Discussion Questions
- Did Wilson Mutambara act wrongly? Explain why or why not. Assess each of the arguments he gives in his own defense. What other courses of action were open to him? What would you have done in his place?
- Was Dale Garman right to confirm the information he had received and to report the matter? Was it morally required of him to do so?
- What should Barbara Weston and NewCom do? Should Wilson be ordered to move out of Old Town and into more appropriate housing? Should he be terminated for having falsified his housing receipts? If not, should he be punished in some other way?
- Is NewCom unfairly imposing its own ethnocentric values on Wilson Mutambara? Is the company’s housing policy fair and reasonable? Is it culturally biased?
Chapter 10
Required Text(s): Business EthicsAuthor(s): William H. ShawEdition: 9thYear: 2021Publisher: Cengage
Chapter 10: Opiates
Key Terms analgesia: Pain relief produced without a loss of consciousness.
heroin: A drug produced by chemically processing morphine. It is more potent than morphine and has become the major opiate drug of harmful use.
naloxone: A short-acting opiate antagonist.
opium: The dried sap produced by the poppy plant.
True or False Questions Answer Key 1. Opium comes from the plant Cannabis sativa. FALSE. Opium comes from the poppy plant Papaver somniferum. 2. Morphine is one of the active ingredients in opium. TRUE. Morphine and codeine are chemicals directly derived from opium. 3. Heroin was first made illegal by the 1965 Drug Abuse Control Amendment. FALSE. All opiates were brought under legal control by the 1914 Harrison Narcotics Tax Act. 4. As of December 2020, not more than 100,000 Americans have died from opiate overdose or dependence. FALSE. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate that over 400,000 Americans have died from opiate overdose or dependence as of December 2020. 5. Fentanyl and its analog compounds are less potent than pure heroin. FALSE. Fentanyl and fentanyl analogs range from ten to hundreds of times more potent than pure heroin. Thus, the risk of overdose is greater. 6. The opiates are among the most powerful analgesic drugs. TRUE. The principal medical use for opiates is to relieve pain. 7. Heroin enhances sexual desire and activity. FALSE. Heroin inhibits sexual arousal. 8. Heroin dependence is a factor of physical withdrawal symptoms, lifestyle, and social environment. TRUE. Heroin dependence is complex. Factors of physical withdrawal symptoms, lifestyle, and social environment all interact to influence the development and maintenance of heroin dependence. 9. Heroin withdrawal is much like alcohol withdrawal. FALSE. Opiate withdrawal does not include delirium tremens but rather is characterized by flu and cold symptoms. 10. Veterans of the Vietnam War had a high rate of heroin dependence and were unable to kick the habit when they returned to the United States. FALSE. Most veterans were able to quit using heroin when they returned to their home environment. 11. The effects of opiates are synergistic with those of alcohol. TRUE. Alcohol and other depressant drugs act synergistically with heroin and other opiates, and these combinations are often fatal.
Chapter 10: Opiates
12. The expression “cold turkey” comes from the “goose bumps” seen in those suffering from heroin withdrawal. TRUE. The resemblance is thought to be the basis for that expression.
- Key Terms
- True or False Questions Answer Key
,
Instructor Manual: Chapter 10: Opiates
Instructor Manual
Maisto, Drug Use and Misuse, 9th edition, ©2022, 9780357375952
Table of Contents Purpose and Perspective of the Chapter 1 Cengage Supplements 1 Learning Objectives 2 Complete List of Chapter Activities and Assessments 2 Key Terms 3 What’s New in This Chapter 3 Chapter Outline 3 True or False Questions Answer Key 5 Discussion Questions 6 Appendix 6 Generic Rubrics 6 Standard Discussion Rubric 7
Purpose and Perspective of the Chapter
As indicated in previous chapters, psychoactive drugs may have potential for improving the human condition, but also have the potential to cause destruction to individuals and society. No group of drugs captures this paradox more dramatically than the class of drugs we call opiates, which includes opium, morphine, heroin, and related compounds. Opiate drugs have been used for centuries to relieve pain and, when introduced to Europe, were hailed by physicians as a godsend. One of the first European physicians to use opium to relieve pain and suffering in his patients, Thomas Sydenham, wrote in 1680: “Among the remedies which it has pleased Almighty God to give man to relieve his sufferings, none is so universal and so efficacious as opium” (Gay & Way, 1972, p. 47). Even today, opiate drugs remain the most potent painkillers available to physicians, yet we now recognize the ability of opiates to produce severe dependence. Heroin is viewed as the prototypical dependence-producing drug, and illegal use and traffic in heroin are major international problems. Thus, many of the general concerns regarding psychoactive drugs emerge in bold relief in a consideration of opiates. An epidemic of dependence on opiate drugs has swept across the United States in recent years, and opiate overdose is a major crisis today. We will first consider the early history of opiate use and then focus on factors that led to the epidemic.
Cengage Supplements
The following product-level supplements provide additional information that may help you in preparing your course. They are available in the Instructor Resource Center.
· Educator’s Guide
· Transition Guide
· Cognero Test Banks
· PowerPoints
Learning Objectives
The following objectives are addressed in this chapter:
10-1 Discuss the historical patterns of opiate use, including how the Harrison Narcotics Tax Act affects opiate use in the United States
10-2 Evaluate the factors contributing to the current opiate epidemic
10-3 Describe how opiates are absorbed, distributed, metabolized, and excreted from the body
10-4 Explain the mechanisms of action for the opiates
10-5 Discuss how opiates are used to treat acute and chronic pain
10-6 Compare and contrast the acute and chronic effects of opiates
10-7 Evaluate the role of physical and environmental factors associated with heroin dependence
Complete List of Chapter Activities and Assessments
For additional guidance refer to the Teaching Online Guide.
Chapter Objective |
PPT Slide |
Activity/Assessment |
Duration |
All Objectives |
PPT: #2 |
Icebreaker |
5 minutes |
10-1 Discuss the historical patterns of opiate use, including how the Harrison Narcotics Tax Act affects opiate use in the United States |
PPT: #4 PPT: #15–16 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 1: History of the Opiates |
5 minutes |
10-2 Evaluate the factors contributing to the current opiate epidemic |
PPT: #11–13 PPT: #15–16 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 1: History of the Opiates |
5 minutes |
10-3 Describe how opiates are absorbed, distributed, metabolized, and excreted from the body |
PPT: #17 PPT: #20–21 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 2: Pharmacokinetics |
5 minutes |
10-4 Explain the mechanisms of action for the opiates |
PPT: #22 PPT: #24–25 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 3: Mechanisms of Opiate Action |
5 minutes |
10-5 Discuss how opiates are used to treat acute and chronic pain |
PPT: #26 PPT: #27–28 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 4: Medical Use of Opiate Drugs |
5 minutes |
10-6 Compare and contrast the acute and chronic effects of opiates |
PPT: #30 PPT: #34–35 PPT: #36 PPT: #41–42 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 5: Acute Psychological and Physiological Effects of Opiates PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 6: Chronic Effects of Opiates |
5 minutes 5 minutes |
10-7 Evaluate the role of physical and environmental factors associated with heroin dependence |
PPT: #36 PPT: #41–42 |
PPT, IM: Knowledge Check 6: Chronic Effects of Opiates |
5 minutes |
Key Terms
analgesia: Pain relief produced without a loss of consciousness.
heroin: A drug produced by chemically processing morphine. It is more potent than morphine and has become the major opiate drug of harmful use.
naloxone: A short-acting opiate antagonist.
opium: The dried sap produced by the poppy plant.
What’s New in This Chapter
The following elements are improvements in this chapter from the previous edition:
· Each chapter of the ninth edition has been updated to represent findings from the latest research, as well as to reflect social and legal changes related to drugs. Among the many revisions, we present the latest survey data available at this writing on patterns of drug use in the United States and in other countries worldwide.
· Chapter 10, “Opiates,” provides extensive new coverage of the dramatic increase in use of heroin, prescription opiates, and synthetic opiates. Two new sections are included on the events that led to the opiate epidemic and the current status and impact of the epidemic. The increase in opiate overdose deaths is chronicled, and we add a new box on treating overdose with naloxone.
[return to top]
Chapter Outline
I. History of the Opiates
a. Early History
b. Opiate Use in the 19th Century
c. Opiate Use after the Harrison Act
d. The Making of an Epidemic
e. The Opiate Epidemic
f. Knowledge Check 1: History of the Opiates (10.1, PPT Slides #15–16), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Question: Chronologically, what is the sequence of the discovery and release of the following drugs?
Answer: d. Opium, morphine, heroin. Opium was used thousands of years ago in ancient civilizations, became a serious dependency problem in China by the early 19th century, and became popular in the modern Western world in the 1800s. Morphine was isolated in 1803 and became widely available by the mid-1800s. Heroin was discovered in 1874 and rediscovered in 1898.
II. Pharmacokinetics
a. Absorption
b. Distribution, Metabolism, and Excretion
c. Knowledge Check 2: Pharmacokinetics (10.2, PPT Slides #20–21), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Question: The opiate ________ passes through the blood-brain barrier more easily than ________; once in the brain, ________ is converted to _______.
Answer: d. heroin; morphine; heroin; morphine. Heroin is more lipid-soluble than morphine and passes through the blood-brain barrier more easily. Once in the brain, heroin is converted to morphine. Thus, heroin more effectively delivers morphine to the brain than morphine itself.
III. Mechanisms of Opiate Action
a. Discovery of Endorphins
b. What Do Endorphins Do?
c. Knowledge Check 3: Mechanisms of Opiate Action (10.3, PPT Slides #24–25), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Question: What are endorphins?
Answer: a. They are the body’s own natural pain relievers. Opiate antagonists like naloxone are not endorphins; they block endorphin receptors. Endorphins are not placebos, which are medically inactive substances given to research volunteers without their knowledge; if subjects believe these are active drugs and thus expect pain relief, they will experience it, probably through endorphin release.
IV. Medical Use of Opiate Drugs
a. Knowledge Check 4: Medical Use of Opiate Drugs (10.4, PPT Slides #28–29), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Answer: e. To relieve all of these. Various opiate drugs are used medically to relieve pain, coughs, and heroin withdrawal symptoms, and in maintenance programs to aid ongoing abstinence from heroin use.
V. Acute Psychological and Physiological Effects of Opiates
a. Knowledge Check 5: Acute Psychological and Physiological Effects of Opiates (10.5, PPT Slides #34–35), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Question: Which of the following is a common acute physiological effect of opiate drugs?
Answer: d. Respiratory depression or failure. Opiates cause respiratory depression. When a high dose of heroin is fatal, the immediate cause is usually respiratory failure. Reduced sex drive, impotence, and impairment in social interactions and cognitive functions are all common acute psychological effects of opiate drugs.
VI. Chronic Effects of Opiates
a. Tolerance
b. Withdrawal and Dependence
c. Knowledge Check 6: Chronic Effects of Opiates (10.6, PPT Slides #41–42), 5 minutes total, multiple-choice question and answer.
Question: Researchers have found that when morphine or heroin was always available, a human and a rhesus monkey did which of the following?
Answer: b. Both increased the dose gradually over time. Neither the human nor the rhesus monkey increased the dose almost immediately or quickly. The similar patterns of self-administration between the human and the monkey illustrate the generality of the emergence of tolerance to the rewarding consequences of opiate drugs.
d. Summary
True or False Questions Answer Key
1. Opium comes from the plant Cannabis sativa.
FALSE. Opium comes from the poppy plant Papaver somniferum.
2. Morphine is one of the active ingredients in opium.
TRUE. Morphine and codeine are chemicals directly derived from opium.
3. Heroin was first made illegal by the 1965 Drug Abuse Control Amendment.
FALSE. All opiates were brought under legal control by the 1914 Harrison Narcotics Tax Act.
4. As of December 2020, not more than 100,000 Americans have died from opiate overdose or dependence.
FALSE. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention indicate that over 400,000 Americans have died from opiate overdose or dependence as of December 2020.
5. Fentanyl and its analog compounds are less potent than pure heroin.
FALSE. Fentanyl and fentanyl analogs range from ten to hundreds of times more potent than pure heroin. Thus, the risk of overdose is greater.
6. The opiates are among the most powerful analgesic drugs.
TRUE. The principal medical use for opiates is to relieve pain.
7. Heroin enhances sexual desire and activity.
FALSE. Heroin inhibits sexual arousal.
8. Heroin dependence is a factor of physical withdrawal symptoms, lifestyle, and social environment.
TRUE. Heroin dependence is complex. Factors of physical withdrawal symptoms, lifestyle, and
social environment all interact to influence the development and maintenance of heroin
dependence.
9. Heroin withdrawal is much like alcohol withdrawal.
FALSE. Opiate withdrawal does not include delirium tremens but rather is characterized by flu and cold symptoms.
10. Veterans of the Vietnam War had a high rate of heroin dependence and were unable to kick the habit when they returned to the United States.
FALSE. Most veterans were able to quit using heroin when they returned to their home environment.
11. The effects of opiates are synergistic with those of alcohol.
TRUE. Alcohol and other depressant drugs act synergistically with heroin and other opiates, and these combinations are often fatal.
12. The expression “cold turkey” comes from the “goose bumps” seen in those suffering from heroin withdrawal.
TRUE. The resemblance is thought to be the basis for that expression.
Discussion Questions
You can assign these questions several ways: in a discussion forum in your LMS, as whole-class discussions in person, or as a partner or group activity in class.
1. Discussion: The Opiate Epidemic (p. 270, 10.1, PPT Slide #12) Duration 15 minutes.
a. An essential paradox inherent in opiates is that they are the most effective known painkillers, yet they are also highly addictive.
b. What are some ways that doctors can manage their patients’ pain more effectively, with fewer or no harmful side effects?
i. Answer: Answers will vary. Some students may recall the text’s discussion of physicians’ historical caution in prescribing opiates and say that they should return to those practices, stop overprescribing them, and only allow their short-term use to relieve severe, acute pain. Some students may recommend that researchers work harder to seek alternatives for pain relief that are not addictive. If no students bring these up, remind them of: Research findings of differences in mechanism of action between therapeutic opioids and endorphins, which could inform designing novel, nonaddictive therapeutics, on p. 273; the new (2016) CDC guidelines cited on p. 276; and the Contemporary Issue Box 10.3 on p. 276 about partial opiate agonists like buprenorphine as one safer alternative. Some students may also bring up existing alternative methods of pain relief, such as acupuncture; reinforce this by citing the text’s inclusion of acupuncture in the discussion of endorphins on p. 274.
c. What are some events cited in your text that represent government attempts to address the growing opiate epidemic, and some parallel events that represent a continuing epidemic despite those attempts?
i. Answer: In 2001, the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) pressured Purdue Pharma to discontinue the highest dose of OxyContin; however, widespread misuse of this drug did not stop, and even the Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (JCAHO) encouraged prescribing opiates (using teaching materials, some developed by Purdue Pharma), suggesting that concerns about addiction and death risks were exaggerated. Also, several U.S. state governments filed lawsuits, and in 2007, Purdue Pharma was fined and paid $634 million for misrepresenting OxyContin’s misuse liability; however, in 2008, deaths from drug overdoses, mostly of opiates, exceeded auto accidents as the United States’ leading cause of death.
Appendix
Generic Rubrics
Providing students with rubrics helps them understand expectations and components of assignments. Rubrics help students become more aware of their learning process and progress, and they improve students’ work through timely and detailed feedback.
Customize these rubric templates as you wish. The writing rubric indicates 40 points and the discussion rubric indicates 30 points.
Standard Discussion Rubric
Criteria |
Meets Requirements |
Needs Improvement |
Incomplete |
Participation |
Submits or participates in discussion by the posted deadlines. Follows all assignment. Instructions for initial post and responses. 5 points |