To help you design your survey use the following resources as a guide: Measuring Leader’s effectiveness as discussed in Chapters 8 and 9 in our text Harnessing D
- To help you design your survey use the following resources as a guide:
- Measuring Leader's effectiveness as discussed in Chapters 8 and 9 in our text
- Harnessing Discretionary Performance model, found in Week 3’s readings and research
- The positive examples in Chapter 10 of Measure of a Leader
- The negative examples in Allison Vaillancourt's (2007) article Avoiding the Top 10 Metrics Mistakes
- When you create your survey, develop at least three questions from each of the Harnessing Discretionary Performance model elements (Direction, Ability, Competence, Opportunity, Measures, Feedback, and Consequences). Focus on what you specifically observe leaders in your organization “Do” to harness Discretionary Effort.
- Distribute the survey to at least five people in your organization. Survey responses should be anonymous. To the extent possible, include at least two people who report to you, two peers/colleagues, and one person to whom you report. If you have no people reporting to you, distribute the survey to additional peers/colleagues.
- In addition, complete a self–assessment of your leadership skills by completing the survey for yourself.
- Collect the (2) completed groups of surveys and analyze the results, noting the questions below.
- To what extent do your leadership survey results agree with your self–assessment of your leadership skills? What factors do you think account for this agreement?
- To what extent do your leadership survey results contradict your self–assessment of your leadership skills? What factors do you think account for any discrepancies?
- What, if any, variances do you see in the survey results among subordinates, peers, and/or your leader? Why do you think any variances exist? If no variances exist, what circumstances do you think contribute to the alignment of your self–assessment and the assessments of others?
- What is the most important thing that you learned about yourself as a leader as a result of doing this survey?
- What one thing about your survey results surprised you most? Why?
How To Quickly Measure Your Success as a Leader (transcript)
Harnessing Discretionary Performance
(Written by H. G. Buschang, HGB Associates)
Leaders of high performing organizations are especially adept at creating an environment that helps people feel good about doing a good job. The basic elements characterizing high performing organizations are deceptively simple. They are easy to understand and are almost intuitive. However, their implementation and institutionalization require forethought, planning and effort, and in most cases, significant changes in behavior. To harness Discretionary Performance, the following model may be helpful.
D irection
Can Perform
A bility
C competence
O pportunity
M easures
F eedback
WWant to Perform
(Motivation)_
C onsequences
Let’s briefly look at each of these in a bit more detail.
“Can Perform” – The following elements are necessary for people to know “what” to do and to create the capacity for them to do it.
D – Direction – If you are unaware of the expectations, you may not perform as expected. Also, if the direction is not clear, confusion can result. You may not draft a report if you did not know it was expected, you may not perform as expected if there are three conflicting priorities or unstated interpretations of ‘doing a quality job’ (such as customer responsiveness, speed and accuracy). Common elements may include:
· Clarity of shared Vision, Mission, Principles/Values
· Articulation and alignment of Strategy, Initiatives, Goals and Objectives
A – Ability – This refers to the physical capability or ability to perform the tasks required by the change. You cannot run a 2-minute mile, you cannot have concurrent meetings in two locations, you cannot climb 40 stairs with heavy equipment if you have a broken leg.
C – Competence – Does the organization have the Technical, Interpersonal, Work Management and Leadership skills necessary to achieve the Vision of the organization? If you were switched to a new software application or hardware platform, if you are expected to lead a project or team or if you asked to present to a large audience, you might lack the skills or knowledge required to successfully meet the new demands.
O – Opportunity – There are many dimensions that relate to this item. You may not have the time or resources (people, materials or funds), or you may not have the processes, information or authority to adopt the new changes. In this case, perception may be as strong a resistance point as reality. Another way to think about “Opportunity” is to consider whether people have the necessary resources and support to accomplish their goals.
“Want to Perform” (Motivation) – The following elements are necessary for to create an environment in which people “want to” perform at high levels. Leaders have the responsibility to create an environment in which people want to do their best every day. Once you have the direction, ability, competence and opportunity you still might not have the interest or drive to do your best. You do not see the W-I-I-F-M (What’s in it for Me?). Motivation is the most important of the five characteristics because it can help accommodate deficiencies in any of the other four elements. Highly motivated people will find the time, will learn the skills, will seek direction, will take chances. Motivation is the main factor that determines whether the change is sustained or not. Key elements of Motivation include:
M – Measures – Does the organization have timely, credible ways to measure both the desired business results as well as the behaviors (what people do) to achieve the results? Are the measures used to properly align performance? Are they meaningful and easily accessible to the performers, and most importantly, is the performance that is measures truly in the control of the performer? It is important to have clarity on what will be measures, how frequently, by whom, and how the data will be used. Measures form the basis for effective feedback.
F – Feedback – One of the most important leadership skills is to provide data-based feedback. Feedback is knowledge about performance. Good feedback is knowledge about performance that is timely and specific enough to allow performance to change. A few characteristics about good feedback is that it is specific and data-based, timely, understandable and active. Feedback should only be offered with the purpose of helping the recipient of feedback become successful in what they are doing.
C – Consequences – What people do (behaviors) is a function of the consequences they experience (or expect to experience) when they do it. The effectiveness of what leaders do is determined by how they use behavioral consequences. While most leaders believe that consequences are in place, experience has shown that the consequences that are typically used are often ineffective in either maintaining desirable action or in stopping undesirable actions. Daniels, pg. 97)
Conclusion
Leaders of high performing organizations embody a consistent, systematic way to help people understand how what they do on a day-to-day basis contributes to the success of the organization. They ensure that people have the necessary abilities, skills and knowledge and remove real (and perceived) barriers to success. They provide frequent and honest feedback on how well the organization, the team and the individuals are performing. These concepts are surprising simple, yet require forethought, planning and leadership effort to implement successfully.
Daniels, Aubrey C. and Daniels, James E. (2007). Measure of a Leader. McGraw-Hill.
,
Leadership Measures
Measurement
Measurement is both science and art.
Science because it can be qualitative or quantitative and is based on the rules of statistics.
Art because effective measures are linked to day-to- day recognition and reinforcement and to longer term rewards for enhanced performance and results.
Purpose of Measures
- Basis for aligning performance
- Basis for tracking achievement and assessing progress
- Basis for objective feedback and corrective action
- Basis for Reinforcement and Rewards
Align
Achieve
Adapt
Purpose of Measuring Leadership
The most significant reason to measure ”leadership” is for the leader’s own development.
To objectively separate “apparent” effect from “actual” effect of the leader’s actions.
To assess actual leadership effectiveness Vs. “personality.”
Characteristics of
Effective Measures
Clarity
well defined; easy to understand; indicate what is necessary day-to-day
Focus
“zeroing” in on what truly needs to be accomplished
Alignment
everyone is working toward same end result
Rallyable
performance improvements are seen; good progress is reflected by measures that go up rather than down
Line of Sight
measures clearly linked to others units and the organization as a whole
Value Added
assesses what is important; focus is on who value is created; begins with stakeholder
Accessible
measures are accessible to the performer on a continuous and timely basis
Performer Control
Performers can influence the outcomes; reflect the activities of the performers
Consistency
improved work processes enhances performance and measures
Common Errors of
Measurement
Measuring Too Much
Infrequent and Delayed Feedback
Measuring Results Only
Lack of Reinforcement
Measuring the Wrong Things
Common Resistance to Measurement
Common Reasons
Suggested Approaches
“Some jobs can’t be measured”
Measures can be developed for any effort
“Establishing a measurement system is time consuming and expensive”
Simple systems have the best chance for success and cost the least.
“Things beyond our control are being measured”
It is important to measure what the individual can control.
Resistance indicates that people are anticipating a change and are taking measurement seriously.
“The measures will be used to punish performance”
Measures are used to gauge progress and give guidance. The focus is on behaviors, not just results.
Measuring the Leader’s Effectiveness
What did the leader accomplish?
How did the followers respond?
What do leaders do (their specific leadership behaviors) to achieve the above? Covered in Chapters 11 through 18 in upcoming weeks)
Measuring the Leader’s Accomplishments
Did they grow the enterprise?
Did their organization achieve some level of prominence?
Did the leader leave a positive legacy?
Measuring Follower Response
How many followers respond to the leader’s call?
How does it take for the followers to take action?
How closely do the followers’ behaviors match the leader’s priorities?
How many people can relate their efforts to the leader’s vision?
How many people can relate an example of the leader’s values?
How many people meet their commitments?
How many individuals assist their peers?
How many units actively assist other units?
How many suggestions are made in support of the visions?
How often do followers take responsibility for their mistakes?
How often do followers seek the leaders advice?
How many followers become leaders?
Leadership Behaviors
What Leaders “Do” to Achieve Desired Outcomes
Provide Direction: Align expectations throughout the organization
Develop Competence: Ensure that people have the skills and knowledge to achieve the vision
Enable Followers: Provide the necessary resources to achieve the vision
Measure Performance: Create a system of objective and timely measures for both outcomes and supporting behaviors
Provide Feedback: Let people know how they are doing
Motivate Followers: Be an effective consequence provider
Leadership Measurement Options
Counts Objective
Behavior Anchored Scales
Ratings
Rankings Subjective
Summary Thoughts
Leadership effectiveness is not random. It is governed by the laws of human behavior.
Leaders provide clarity on the behaviors they need people to engage in . . to achieve the mission of their organization.
Leaders utilize measure for their own development.
The role of leaders is to become effective consequence providers.
,
Discretionary Effort
Discretionary effort can best be described as the extra level of performance people (could) give when they want to do something as opposed to when they feel like they have to something. People often refer to this as the difference between commitment (doing it because we want to) and compliance (doing it because we have to…or else!).
Behaviorally speaking, discretionary performance will occur only when (the desired) behavior is positively reinforced. Positive reinforcement can come from sources internal to the person (we call that intrinsic motivation) as well as from the environment surrounding him or her. If people do only enough to avoid experiencing negative consequences, discretionary performance will not occur.
As leaders, we must ask ourselves, are we creating a work environment where employees “want to” give extra effort? Are we positively reinforcing those behaviors when we see them? If the answer to those questions is “yes,” there is a high probability that we encouraging discretionary effort in the workplace. (Braksick, 2000)
Braksick, L, Unlock Behavior, Unleash Profits, McGraw-Hill, 2000
Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers
Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.
Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS
Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?
Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.
We write plagiarism Free Content
Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.
Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.