Ralph Arvizu was stopped by a border patrol agent in southern Arizona, for suspected contraband smuggling.
United States v. Arvizu Case Brief
Fourth Amendment to the Constitution: Unreasonable Search and Seizure
Title and Citation: U.S. v. Arvizu, 122 S.Ct. 744 (2002)
Type of Action: SCOTUS review of a 9th Circuit Appellate Court decision, violation of the 4th Amendment, warrantless stop, search and seizure of a motor vehicle based on totality of the circumstances and reasonable suspicion.
Facts of the Case: Ralph Arvizu was stopped by a border patrol agent in southern Arizona, for suspected contraband smuggling. After receiving consent to search the vehicle from the respondent, Agent Stoddard discovered more than 100 pounds of marijuana in the vehicle. Respondent was subsequently arrested and charged with possession with intent to distribute marijuana. Respondent made motions at trial to suppress evidence, which were denied by the courts. Subsequently, Arvizu entered a conditional guilty plea based on the mounted evidence against him.
Upon completion of the case in the District of Arizona court, Arvizu appealed to the 9th Circuit
Court of Appeals. The appellate court reversed and remanded the case stating that the Agent Stoddard had no reasonable suspicion that criminal activity was occurring or had occurred. The government was grated certiorari by the SCOTUS to consider and opine the case.
Contentions of the Parties:
Ralph Arvizu: Argues that the stop was a violation of his 4th amendment right to freedom from unreasonable stop, search and seizure. Arvizu argued that the agent had no reasonable suspicion that criminal activity was present or had been committed.
United States: The U.S. argues that the Agent, through his training and/or experience in contraband smuggling, interdiction, and human smuggling, resulted in the totality of the circumstances which he used to develop reasonable suspicion necessary to validly stop the vehicle driven by Arvizu.
Issue: Did the Agent violate Arvizu’s 4th amendment right of freedom from unreasonable search and seizure by conducting a stop based on reasonable suspicion that criminal acts had taken place or were taking place?
Decision: No, SCOTUS reversed and remanded the case to the District Court, stating that the Appellate Court did not consider the totality of the circumstances which the Agent utilized to develop his own reasonable suspicion to conduct the stop, which led to the discovery of contraband.
Rational: SCOTUS
determined that the Appellate Court wrongfully analyzed single factors which the Agent used to develop his belief that illegal activity was occurring. The Appellate Court further used its authority to delegitimize the elements Agent Stoddard used to develop his reasonable suspicion, claiming they were both uncertain and unpredictable relative to fourth amendment rights. SCOTUS clearly said that the Appellate Court wrongfully compartmentalized the factors which Agent Stoddard inferred for his reasonable suspicion to conduct the traffic stop. Had the Appellate Court combined all of the factors together, they would have seen Agent Stoddard acted within his authority. Given the specific training and experience with interdiction and smuggling which Agent Stoddard had, the Appellate Court should have combined all factors and conclude, much as the district court had, that Agent Stoddard acted appropriately and within the law
Rule of Law: SCOTUS reiterated that the 4th Amendment prohibits unreasonable search and seizure. Each reasonable suspicion stop is a potential violation and the facts must be analyzed with regard to the totality of the circumstances.
Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers
Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.
Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS
Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?
Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.
We write plagiarism Free Content
Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.
Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.
