A Literature Review Table provides a succinct overview of each article. The table is especially useful when synthesizing the inf
A Literature Review Table provides a succinct overview of each article. The table is especially useful when synthesizing the information from the articles into your Literature Review, as the main elements are clearly identified.
Complete the Literature Review Table using the articles identified from your literature search that will be used in your Literature Review. This assignment should have 6 attachments: The completed Literature Review Table and the 5 articles reviewed in the table.
Students will be able to resubmit the Literature Review Table assignment one time.
Literature Table (3).xlsx October 20 2021, 3:06 PM
Sheet1
Citation | Research Question | Study Design | Sample Size and Method | Independent Variables and Measures | Dependent Variables and Measures | Results | General Strengths | General Weaknesses | Overall Quality of Study | Summary Statements for Practice | Column12 | Column13 |
Jimenez, C., Navia‐Osorio, P. M., & Diaz, C. V. (2010). Stress and health in novice and experienced nursing students. Journal of advanced nursing, 66(2), 442-455. | What are the differences in novice and experienced nursing students' reports of stress and health? | Case-control study | Cross-sectional research was performed using standard information gathering tools. The study was carried out with 357 students from all three years of a nursing diploma programme at spanish nursing college. The data were collected over n 8-month period in 2004-2005. | Nursing students' reports | Stress and Health | Three types of stressors were identified which are clinical, external, and academic and two categories of symptoms which are psychological and physiological were linked to clinical practice. | Reliability, versatility – what is versatility? | Limited access to data, time constraints | Good | students should be informed about possible stressors associated with their profession, and introducing interventions to support development of professionalism, social skills and coping capacity for clinical practice. | ||
Chu, L., McGrath, J. M., Qiao, J., Brownell, E., Recto, P., Cleveland, L. M., … & McGlothen-Bell, K. (2022). A Meta-Analysis of Breastfeeding Effects for Infants With Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome. Nursing research, 71(1), 54-65. | Does breastfeeding results in better outcomes for NAS infants? | This is a type of review article, which is not allowed for this assignment Meta-analysis | PubMed, Scopus, Embase, and Cochrane Library were searched from 2000 to 2020, and comparative studies examining breastfeeding for NAS infants were extracted. Randomized trials and cohort studies were included. Data were extracted and evaluated with Review Manager Version 5.3. A random-effects model was used to pool discontinuous outcomes using risk ratio and 95% confidence intervals. Continuous outcomes were evaluated by mean differences and 95% confidence intervals. | Symptom severity | Need for and duration of pharmacological treatment, and length of hospital stay | Across 11 studies, 6,375 neonates were included in the meta-analysis. Using a random-effects analysis, breastfeeding reduced initiation of pharmacological treatment, reduced duration of pharmacological treatment, and reduced length of stay. No differences were detected for severity of NAS symptoms. Most studies only reported one to two variables of interest. For most studies, these variables were not the primary study outcomes. All studies were found to be of low risk and good quality based on the Cochrane Risk Assessment Tools. Varying breastfeeding definitions limit generalizability. | Reliability | Time constraints | Good | Breastfeeding is associated with decreased initiation and duration of pharmacological treatment and length of stay. | ||
Wiggermann, N., Smith, K., & Kumpar, D. (2017). What bed size does a patient need? The relationship between body mass index and space required to turn in bed. Nursing research, 66(6), 483. | how much space individuals occupy when turning from supine to side lying as predicted by their anthropometry? | Case-control study | Forty-seven adult participants (24 female) with body mass index (BMI) from 20 to 76 kg/m2 participated in a laboratory study. Body dimensions were measured, and the envelope of space required to turn was determined using motion capture. Linear regressions estimated the relationship between anthropometric attributes and space occupied when turning. | Space | Body dimension | BMI was strongly correlated (R2 = .88) with the space required to turn. Based on the linear regressions, individuals with BMI up to 35 kg/m2 could turn left and right within 91 cm and individuals with BMI up to 45 kg/m2 could turn one direction within 91 cm. | versatility, reliability | time constraints | Good | Body Mass Index (BMI) is a good predictor of the space required to turn from supine to lateral | ||
Roy, C. (2018). Key issues in nursing theory: Developments, challenges, and future directions. Nursing Research, 67(2), 81-92. | What are the development and contributions of theory? | systematic review | A personal narrative along with literature reviews. Narrative strategies included my own publications on theory, some relevant unpublished speeches, memories of meetings checked with concurrent attendees, and similar or dissimilar points of view in nursing theory textbooks. | Development and contributions of theory | Challenges | Contributions of theoretical work in the 20th century included maturing of the discipline, clarifying the theoretical focus of nursing as holistic persons with processes and patterns for environmental integration to attain health, a plurality of grand theories for articulating and testing of theories in practice and research, identification of the mutual impact of theory and education and major conferences, and contributions globally. | Reliability | limited access to data | Good | The potential of this structure for developing future theory-based nursing knowledge for practice is envisioned, and strategies for creating this future are suggested. | ||
Spratling, R., & Lawrence, R. H. (2019). Facilitators and barriers to minority blood donations: A systematic review. Nursing research, 68(3), 218-226. | What are the facilitators and barriers to blood donation in minority populations? | Systematic review – not appropriate | Beginning August 2017, we conducted a literature search using the following electronic databases: CINAHL Plus with Full Text, Academic Search Complete, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, Sociological Collection, Cochrane Library, ProQuest Dissertation and Theses, and PubMed, which continued through December 2017. Based on primarily descriptive data in the articles (n = 15), the systematic review proceeded as a meta-synthesis. An inductive approach was used to analyze commonalities, differences, patterns, and themes in the study findings; interpret the findings; and synthesize the findings to generate new knowledge about the phenomena of study. | Facilitators, barriers | blood donation | The themes included knowing a blood recipient, identifying with culture, ethnicity, and religious affiliation; and medical mistrust and misunderstanding. All were prominent in the descriptions of minorities on blood donation and exist as facilitators and barriers. | Reliability | limited access to data | Good | Facilitators and barriers to minority blood donations are complex and exist concurrently | ||
PICOT: | What is the PICO? It is hard to assess whether the articles relate to the PICO if the PICO is not present | |||||||||||
Databases: | ||||||||||||
Key Words: |
,
PICOT Question:
A patient of age 40 years is diagnosed with some lung problems and admitted to hospital. How effective will be the strategy of cessation of smoking for the period of two months to overcome the lung problems as compared to chemotherapy and inhalers. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Look to the textbook and the PICO sample in Moodle for assistance with the proper formatting of a PICO question. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: This PICO is too general and is medical-related rather than nursing-related. Are you interested in smoking cessation therapies? Your PICO could be something about that. Example: “In adult smokers (P), how effective are nurse-led smoking cessation programs (I) versus standard therapy (C), in assisting smokers to quit smoking (O)?”
P |
Patient with age of 4o years admitted to hospital. According to the American Cancer Society, roughly 235,760 new cases of lung cancer are diagnosed each year, with males accounting for 119,100 new cases and women accounting for 116,660 new cases. Furthermore, lung cancer claims the lives of approximately 131,880 people, with 69,410 men and 62,470 women (Lung Cancer Statistics, n.d.). According to the American Cancer Society's study, lung cancer is by far the most common cause of cancer mortality, accounting for 25% of all cancer fatalities (Lunger Cancer Statistics, n.d.). Lung cancer is a long-term illness that involves the development of malignant cells in the lungs. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: If your population includes those with lung cancer, that should be included in the PICO Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Don’t use sources that don’t have a date for this class |
I |
Cessation of smokingSmoking cessation program. Continuous research and technological developments have enabled researchers to conduct investigations that have led to clinical trials. Many research and clinical trials have been conducted in order to determine the most prevalent cause of lung cancer in patients, as well as the success of smoking cessation. According to one research, there is a compelling case for delivering smoking cessation therapies to patients who smoke and are being screened for lung cancer (Joseph. A, 2018). Not to add that successful smoking cessation programmes may help to lower cancer and cardiovascular disease mortality and morbidity rates (Joseph. A, 2018). Another research found that smoking increases the risk of lung cancer and other lung problems (Lederer. D, 2009). Comment by Rebecca Coffin: You should talk about smoking cessation programs here |
C |
Chemotherapy and Inhalers Though smoking cessation therapies have been shown to improve quality of life and reduce the morbidity and death rates associated with lung cancer, it is important to remember that such interventions are prohibitively costly. However, evidence shows that a smoking cessation intervention enhances ACERS, making its inclusion in any screening program a strong recommendation (Goffin. J, 2016). Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Smoking cessation won’t cure lung cancer, so you’ll need to rethink your PICO if that is the direction you are going Comment by Rebecca Coffin: What is this? Spell out abbreviations the first time they are used in a paper |
O |
Prevention of complications due to smoking Comment by Rebecca Coffin: This would be a reasonable outcome, but hard to measure. You are looking for success with smoking cessation, so consider that to be the outcome In a clinical examination of smokers in NSLT, 70 percent pondered quitting, 13 percent were ready to stop, and 13 percent had no intention of quitting, according to research (Joseph. A, 2018). While participating in the New York Early Cancer Action Project, 32% were serious about stopping in 30 days and 47% were thinking about quitting in six months (Joseph. A, 2018). The American Thoracic Society and the American College of Chest Physicians have issued a set of guidelines to help build successful lung cancer screening methods in terms of personnel and preparation for smoking cessation interventions (Joseph. A, 2018). On-site clinical professionals, as well as radiologists, are used to conduct smoking cessation therapy. On-site personnel, on the other hand, vary in terms of training and comfort in administering smoking cessation therapy (Joseph. A, 2018). Comment by Rebecca Coffin: What is this? |
T |
Two months period Smoking cessation therapies are administered via psychological and behavioural approaches, with the former requiring no medication and the latter requiring it. Nurses are crucial in influencing a patient's desire to stop smoking. Nurses serve as a connection between the patient and the smoking cessation intervention because they are encouraged to speak with their patients about quitting smoking. Furthermore, they must be appropriately trained in order to give patients with viable choices as well as enrolling them in the right smoking cessation programme (Carlebach. S, 2009). Overall, nurses are or should be motivated by the desire to help their patients improve and maintain their health habits, as well as the urge to engage in preventive care. Smoking cessation nurses will be able to integrate evidence-based strategies in their practises, improving patient health and lowering lung cancer-related mortality. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: I don’t think you need a T (time) for this question. If you want one, you might want to go longer than 2 months for smoking cessation |
References Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Check APA guidelines – many errors in formatting noted below
Lung Cancer Statistics: How Common is Lung Cancer? American Cancer Society. (n.d.). https://www.cancer.org/cancer/lung-cancer/about/key-statistics.html#:~:text=Lung
Nakao, K. (2012). Smoking history and underlying lung disease are associated with poor outcome in patients developing interstitial pneumonia during low-dose amiodarone therapy. Journal of Arrhythmia, 29(1), 5–8. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joa.2012.04.005
Joseph, A., Rothman, A., Almirall, D., Begnaud, A., Chiles, C., Cinciripini, P., Fu, S., Graham, A., Lindgren, B., Melzer, A., Ostroff, J., Seaman, E., Taylor, K., Toll, B., Zeliadt, S., & Vock, D. (2018). Lung Cancer Screening and Smoking Cessation Clinical Trials SCALE (Smoking Cessation within the Context of Lung Cancer Screening) Collaboration. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 197(2), 172– 182. https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.201705-0909CI
Lederer, D., Enright, P., Kawut, S., Hoffman, E., Hunninghake, G., van Beek, E., Austin, J., Jiang, R., Lovasi, G., & Barr, R. (2009). Cigarette Smoking Is Associated with Subclinical Parenchymal Lung Disease: The Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis (MESA)-Lung Study. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine, 180(5), 407–414. https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.200812-1966OC
Goffin, J., Flanagan, W., Miller, A., Fitzgerald, N., Memon, S., Wolfson, M., & Evans, W. (2016). Biennial lung cancer screening in Canada with smoking cessation—outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Lung Cancer (Amsterdam, Netherlands), 101, 98–103. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lungcan.2016.09.013
Carlebach, S., & Hamilton, S. (2009). Understanding the nurse's role in smoking cessation. British Journal of Nursing, 18(11), 672-676.
,
1
Running Head: PICOT QUESTION
2
PICOT QUESTION
PICOT Question:
In adult smokers 40 years and older, how effective are nurse led smoking cessations program versus standard therapy, in assisting smokers to quit smoking within two months?
P |
Patient with age of 40 years admitted to hospital. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: If this is the population, then “admitted to the hospital” needs to be in the PICO as well – you need to be consistent According to Erhardt, L. (2009) smoking has many risk factors especially if it is undertreated. Those effects of smoking are evident even from an early stage. An adult smoker may be at risk of cardiovascular diseases. However, the adverse effects of smoking may be reversible through smoking cessation than standard therapy. |
I |
Nurse led smoking cessation program. Through various cessation research, it has was found that intensive nurse led cessations are effective in helping smokers to quit. According to the national evaluation, four-week carbon monoxide monitoring validated quit rates of 53%, falling to 15% in a year. However, old adults appear to have long-term quit rates than other groups. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: There is no citation here. You should discuss research from at least one nurse-led smoking cessation program |
C |
Versus standard therapy Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Give some examples of standard therapies According to Herman, A. I., & Sofuoglu, M. (2010) smoking is a major public problem that causes more than five million deaths annually worldwide. The health care costs of smoking exceed 400 billion dollars each year. Nurse led smoking cessation program is cheaper compared to standard therapy. Also, quitting smoking is associated with immediate health benefits irrespective of age or smoking related disease. Thus, nurse led smoking cessation is better than standard therapy. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Where is the support for these statements? |
O |
Assisting smokers to quit Nurse led smoking cessation program is most effective in assisting smokers to quit smoking. According to Meysman et al. 2010, there was reduction in the number of patient who smoke that undergone nurse led smoking cessation program. Hospitalized patients experience higher self-confidence to stop smoking after receiving brief advice. The cessation program should be brief and should not impose a large additional workload or require new resources for it to be effective. Comment by Rebecca Coffin: Be careful with these types of statements Comment by Rebecca Coffin: This section should be in the “I” section as rationale Here you should be talking about why it is important to quit smoking, what the general success/relapse rate is, things like that |
T |
Within two months Comment by Rebecca Coffin: You probably don’t need this section There is no specific time frame for a hospitalized patient to quit smoking but according to many patients, they quit smoking within the first two months of the program. Standard therapy may take longer than nurse led smoking cessation program ("Nurse-led Smoking Cessation Program With Follow-up in Healthy Life Centres: a Randomized Clinical Trial – Full Text View – ClinicalTrials.gov", 2022). |
References
Erhardt, L. (2009). Cigarette smoking: an undertreated risk factor for cardiovascular disease. Atherosclerosis, 205(1), 23-32.
Herman, A. I., & Sofuoglu, M. (2010). Comparison of available treatments for tobacco addiction. Current psychiatry reports, 12(5), 433-440.
Meysman, M., Boudrez, H., Nackaerts, K., Dieriks, B., Indemans, R., & Vermeire, P. (2010). Smoking cessation rates after a nurse-led inpatient smoking cessation intervention. Journal of Smoking Cessation, 5(1), 69-76.
Nurse-led Smoking Cessation Program With Follow-up in Healthy Life Centres: a Randomized Clinical Trial – Full Text View – ClinicalTrials.gov. Clinicaltrials.gov. (2022). Retrieved 25 January 2022, from https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT05049174.
,
Sheet1
Citation | Research Question | Study Design | Sample Size and Method | Independent Variables and Measures | Dependent Variables and Measures | Results | General Strengths | General Weaknesses | Overall Quality of Study | Summary Statements for Practice | Column12 | Column13 |
PICOT: | ||||||||||||
Databases: | ||||||||||||
Key Words: |
,
Sheet1
Citation | Research Question | Study Design | Sample Size and Method | Independent Variables and Measures | Dependent Variables and Measures | Results | General Strengths | General Weaknesses | Overall Quality of Study | Summary Statements for Practice | Column12 | Column13 |
Powers, J., Peed, J., Burns, L., & Ziemba-Davis, M. (2012). Chlorhexidinebathing and microbial contamination in patients' bath basins. American Journal of Critical Care, 21(5), 338-343. http://dx.doi.org/10.4037/ajcc2012242 | What is the load of bacterial contaminants in wash basins when chlorhexidine gluconate solution is used in place of standard sap and water to wash patients? | Quantitative – Quasi-experimental | 90 wash basins from a medical/surgical ICU – convenience sampling | Patient Demographics; Basin variables (# of days basins were in use, # of days since pt's last bath); Device variables (presence of central catheters, arterial catheters, PICC, ETT, trach, vent, Foley, fecal bags); Infection variables (infection, antibiotics, isolation – all yes/no) | Bacterial growth in basins compared to growth in basins with soap and water from another study | 4.4% growth in chlorhexidine basins vs. 97.8% growth in soap and water basins; Growth in chlorhexidine basins occurred in female patients | Bathing practices and basin storage/handling were standardized in chlorhexidine group | Case-control study (RCT would be stronger evidence); can't compare bathing practices and basin care and storage techniques because case-control design was used | Very good | Soap and water should not be used to bathe patients in ICU setting | ||
Larson, E.L., Ciliberti, T., Chantler, C., Abraham, J., Lazaro, E.M., Venturanza, M., & Pancholi, P. (2004). Comparison of traditional and disposable bed baths in critically ill patients. American Journal of Critical Care, 13(3), 235-241. | In critically ill adult patients, how effective are prepackaged disposable bed baths, versus traditional basin bed baths, in terms of time/quality of bath, microbial counts on skin, nurse satisfaction, and cost (O)? | Quantitative – Quasi-experimental | 40 patients in cardiothoracic ICU, medical ICU, and general surgical ICU – convenience sampling | Each study bath was observed and timed using a bath observation tool (included # of washcloths, pairs of gloves, # of bathers, products, duration of bath, quality aspects); Interrater reliability by observing several baths simulatneously was confirmed by study team members | Microbiological sampling done before and after bath from patient skin; Nurse satisfaction and quality of bath were obtained through 6-question interview with nurses; cost was estimated through cost of product and nurses' time | Time/quality – no difference; microbial counts – no difference in total count, but significatnly higher gram-neg bacteria after traditional bath (p=.04); Nurse satisfaction – significant overall preference for disposable bath, no difference for quality, time significantly shorter to gather supplies for disposable bath (4.05 vs 1.90 minutes, p<.001); Overall cost higher for traditional bath (nurses' time included in cost) | Inter-rater reliability obtained for data collection; different types of patients sampled | Patient satisfaction not assessed | very good | Disposable baths are a desireable form of bathing for patients in ICU settings | ||
You will need 5 primary research articles in total. | ||||||||||||
PICOT: How effective is bathing with chlorhexidine or disposable products (I), versus traditional basin bathing (C), in reducing contamination (O) in critically ill patients (P)? | ||||||||||||
Databases: CINAHL (should have 2-3 academic databases) | ||||||||||||
Key Words: (nursing, bathing patients) – You will probably have a few more key words that you used when searching the literature |
Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers
Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.
Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS
Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?
Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.
We write plagiarism Free Content
Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.
Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.