Assignment: Organizing objects and scenes

Assignment: Organizing objects and scenes

Permalink: https://collepals.com/assignment-organ…jects-and-scenes/ ‎

Remember to read the assigned parts of the textbook too (Chapter 5)

introduction

Think about these questions:

What would it look like if the visual world had no organization at all?

Are we born with the ability to organize the world perceptually? Or are we born with no perceptually organized world and have to learn through experience?

What does a newborn baby see?

Is the organization of the visual world given in the retinal pattern?

Also, think about this: How would an engineer create a “seeing” machine e.g. a machine that can recognize what it is looking at? The machine would obviously have to be connected to some kind of device that could capture images (a camera), but think about it – the camera would only record the intensity of light at various pixels. What is needed is some way to put all of those pixels of light together to create a whole. This organization is not given in the retinal image (nor in the image in the camera example). Therefore, our brains must be involved in taking this raw data and organizing it so that it means something for us.

3

Look at these bi-stable images carefully for a while. Each can be interpreted (organized) in two mutually exclusive ways: the black area as the object, or figure, and the white area as background, or ground. Or vice versa. You will learn about them this week. Now, what is happening here perceptually? What is happening here in the stimulus? Well, perceptually, you can see that you can alternate between the different interpretations of each stimulus. As for the stimulus, nothing changes.

So, what this shows us is the brain or mind’s tendency to organize things visually (and of course with all of the other senses); to try to make sense of what is in front of it given the inverse problem.

These last two slides show us that the brain has the tendency to organize. There seems to be some organizing principle at work. Look at the example on this slide. See how many interepretations of what it is you can come to. What interpretation does your brain prefer? (e.g. black as object, white as background , or vice versa).

5

Introduction

William James called a newborn’s world “a blooming, buzzing confusion” suggesting that it lacks organization

What would it look like if perception had no organization at all?

Perhaps the best description is that it would be like watching a snowstorm of swirling, multicolored confetti resulting from the output of millions of unrelated retinal receptors

The problem of perceptual organization

The problem of grouping:

“I stand at the window and see a house, trees, sky.

Theoretically, I might say that there were 327 brightnesses

and nuances of color. Do I have “327”? No. I have sky,

house, and trees.” (Wertheimer, 1923)

Again, think about it: in the picture above, all that is there are different intensities of light (like different pixels). Why do we see those pixels organized as a house etc and not just lots of different colors? That is the crucial question.

7

The problem of perceptual organization

The concept of perceptual organization originated with the Gestalt psychologists early in the 20th century.

It was one their central concepts in their attack on the atomic assumption of Structuralism

The Structuralists conceived of visual perception as a simple concatenation of sensory atoms, consisting of pointlike color sensations.

This view is local in the sense that each atom is defined by a particular retinal position and thought to be independent of other atoms

The Gestaltists, in contrast, believed that visual perception arose from global interactions within the nervous system and resulted from the overall structure of visual stimulation itself

Max Wertheimer first posed the problem: how are people able to perceive a coherent visual world that is organized into meaningful objects rather than the chaotic juxtaposition of different colors that stimulate the individual retinal receptors

Why does visual experience have the organization it does?

The naïve realist says, “Because it reflects the structure of the external world”

However, the difficulty with this answer is that the visual system does not have direct access to facts about the environment; it has access only to facts about the image projected onto the retina

That is, an organism can only know the world though sensory information

Remember the difference between the proximal stimulus and the distal stimulus- we only have direct access to the proximal stimulus

10

The Gestaltists referred to the naïve realist’s approach as the experience error, because it arises from the false assumption that the structure of perceptual experience is somehow given in the array of light that falls on the retinal mosaic

This optic array contains an infinity of possible organizations only one of which the visual system usually achieves

Stop! And think about how the second bullet point above is true. Look around you. What do you actually see? But how else could your visual experience be organized? (and if you think this is a silly exercise, remember, there are people with all kinds of agnosias who are unable to organize their visual world so that is makes sense). The face that our brains come to similar organizations of the visual world is amazing and needs to be explained.

11

The confusion that underlies the experience error is to suppose that the starting point for vision is the distal stimulus rather than the proximal stimulus

Taking the distal stimulus as the starting point for vision underestimates the difficulty of visual perception because it presupposes that information comes for free

The structure of the environment is more accurately regarded as the result of visual perception than its starting point

Perceptual grouping

Perceptual grouping: how the various elements in a complex display are perceived as “going together”

Think about this throughout the following slides (it’s difficult, but it’s a good meditation) – no perceptual objects are present on the retina; they exist only in our minds, and only as the result of many levels of processing and interpretation applied to the retinal image

And visual disorders bear the above out! People with visual agnosias have no retinal damage; their inability to perceptually organize a scene or an object comes from damage much higher up in the brain

But our minds have an urge to organize!

So, the Gestalt psychologists argued that the brain contains “principles” or “rules” that are built in that enable us to organize the world.

14

The urge to organize!

I hope on this slide you see the patterns that your brain is imposing on the stimulus. I see circles within circles. Squares. Many different patterns. Your brain going from one interpretation to another. Assignment: Organizing objects and scenes

Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers

Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.

Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS

Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?

Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.

We write plagiarism Free Content

Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.

Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.