Compare and contrast these two forms of teaching.? Within your discussion, be sure to address the following questions: What are the central concepts of each method?

Academic Research International ISSN-L: 2223-9553, ISSN: 2223-9944

Vol. 4 No. 6 November 2013

Part-II: Educational and Management Sciences SAVAP International

Copyright © 2013 www.savap.org.pk

www.journals.savap.org.pk

301

EFFECTS OF DIRECT INSTRUCTION AND SOCIAL

CONSTRUCTIVISM ON LEARNERS’ CONGNITIVE DEVELOPMENT:

A COMPARATIVE STUDY

Waitshega Tefo Smitta Moalosi

Department of Educational Foundations, University of Botswana,

BOTSWANA.

[email protected]

ABSTRACT

Direct instruction and Social constructivism are discussed in this paper as different

approaches that can enhance the learner’s cognitive development. Direct instruction

is teacher centered and the teacher is the director in the learning setting. Social

constructivism is learner centered and it enables learners to have ownership in

learning, and to develop their thinking more than those depending much on the

teacher guidance. This paper concludes that, social constructivism can have more

effect on the learner’s cognitive development than direct instruction. Learners will be able to share their ideas and collaborate with others to solve different problems they

encounter in the learning environment.

Keywords: Direct instructions, social constructivism, cognitive development

INTRODUCTION

The discussion in this paper is a comparison of Direct instruction and Social constructivism.

Direct instruction is a teacher centered approach while social constructivism is learner

centered. Teacher centered approaches makes the teacher to have more control in the

learning setting; and learners become passive recipients of information provided for them by

the teacher. In a learner-centered approach, learners construct knowledge and take

responsibility for their own learning. Social constructivism can enhance students’ learning

more than direct instruction approach. This reasoning is supported by discussing direct

instruction, and its four phases, social constructivism, and the four characteristics and situated

cognition.

DIRECT INSTRUCTION

Direct instruction is described as “an instructional model to teach well defined knowledge and skills needed for later learning” (Eggen & Kauchak, 2010, p. 409). Some examples of

direct instruction involve younger students using basic operations to solve math problems, students’ using grammar and punctuation in writing, and chemistry students’ balancing

equations. Eggen and Kauchak (2010) have found that direct instruction is effective when skills involve detailed steps. This is especially helpful in working with students who are low

achievers or with those with disabilities. A description of examples of a direct instruction

lesson are discussed below:

1. State learning objectives and orient students to learn the lesson: The teacher is expected to tell the students what they should be learning.

2. Review prerequisites: A revision of skills and concepts learned in previous lessons).

3. Present new materials: The teacher should is expected to present new information with examples to aid students’ learning.

Academic Research International ISSN-L: 2223-9553, ISSN: 2223-9944

Vol. 4 No. 6 November 2013

Part-II: Educational and Management Sciences SAVAP International

Copyright © 2013 www.savap.org.pk

www.journals.savap.org.pk

302

4. Conduct learning probes: Questions should be used to assess students’ level of

understanding (Slavin, 2012, p.185).

The above characteristics of direct lessons show that most work is done by the teacher.

The four phases of direct instruction are discussed (see Table below). The four phases of

direct instruction are cognitive in nature. Because the researchers mentioned below thought the four phases of direct instruction are related to human memory, it is important to discuss

them. This writer thinks that they represent a cognitive view of direct instruction. Eggen and

Kauchak (2010) suggested that, the model is cognitive and related to the human memory. The

above mentioned researcher’s findings are supported because one of the model’s cognitive

components, attention, is critical in human learning. Information from the environment

reaches the senses (sensory register) and then passes to the working memory when it is

attended to. It will be transferred to the Long-term memory where it will be stored

permanently. Learners can retrieve the information if they need to use it. Also, Eggen and

Kauchak (2010) proposed that Vygotsky’s (1978) notion of scaffolding is related to Direct

Instruction. Scaffolding is a process where an adult or an experienced peer help learners with

some activities, but when learners are capable of working alone; the adult should reduce

his/her guidance. (See the third phase of the model).

Table 1. Relationships between Phases and Cognitive Learning Components and Cognitive-

Based Direct Instruction (Eggen & Kauchak, 2010 p.410)

Phase Cognitive Learning Component

Introduction and Review: Teachers begin with form of introductory focus

and review previous work.

Attract attention

Access prior knowledge from long-term memory.

Developing Understanding:

Teachers describe and model the skill or explain

and present examples of the concept. Teachers

emphasize understanding.

Acquire declarative knowledge about the skill or

concept.

Encode declarative knowledge into long-term

memory.

Guided practice: Students practice the skill or

identify additional examples of the concept, and

the teacher provides scaffolding.

Move through the associative stage of developing

procedural knowledge.

Independent Practice: Students practice on their

own. Develop automaticity with the skill or concept.

The first phase Introduction and Review suggests that learning begins with attention. Students

are expected to pay attention in the beginning of the lesson. The teacher can find out the students’ opinions regarding the lesson by asking them to give descriptions of the ‘problem

asked’ and revise the work they have done to recover “prior knowledge from the long-term memory” (Eggen and Kauchak, 2010, p.411).

The second phase Developing Understanding focuses on the teacher as modeling the skills,

explaining and demonstrating how students should use the skills. In the second phase the

students obtain the ‘declarative and conditional knowledge’ that help them to be able to

adjust, and get used to applying knowledge in various situations. The declarative knowledge

contained in the Long-term memory is characterized by facts, concepts, procedures and rules

(Eggen and Kauchak, 2010).

Guided practice is emphasized in the third phase. Learners practice skills as teachers scaffold

them. The scaffolding metaphor suggests that teachers guide learners through the tasks that

Academic Research International ISSN-L: 2223-9553, ISSN: 2223-9944

Vol. 4 No. 6 November 2013

Part-II: Educational and Management Sciences SAVAP International

Copyright © 2013 www.savap.org.pk

www.journals.savap.org.pk

303

they are engaged in. As learners master the tasks, the teacher must reduce his/her assistance

so that learners can work by themselves without guidance.

The final phase is Independent Practice; the teacher assists students to shift from thinking

about the skill to ‘performing it automatically’. And it encourages responsibility in their

learning and reduces scaffolding as well. The teacher is expected to monitor students

learning. When the teacher monitors students in their learning, it may involve the power of

the teacher over students when working with them, which it is a limitation of the approach.

Social constructivism avoids this limitation by encouraging students take responsibility in

their learning.

SOCIAL CONSTRUCTIVISM

Social constructivism is an aspect of constructivism that suggests that “learners first construct

knowledge in a social context and then individually internalize it” (Eggen and Kauchak,

2010, p. 227). Social constructivism is a process by which more knowledgeable adults or

experienced peers provide guidance which leads to transmission of knowledge so that higher

mental functions and develop in the social learning environment.

Social constructivism helps us to understand the teacher’s role in the learning setting. Teachers use the question methods with instructions and they organize and use learning

activities, motivating and assessing students. The main focus of the social constructivism approach is to facilitate “students’ constructions of knowledge using social interaction”

Flemingo and Alexander (as cited in Eggen & Kauchak, 2010 p.349).

The social constructivism view is, when the learning environment is created by

knowledgeable others, learners have the ability to exchange their ideas as well as collaborate

with others to solve problems. Santrock, (2009) added “in this way, experience in social

contexts provide an important mecha nism for the development of students’ thinking” (p.349). And teacher- centered approaches enable the teacher to be in control of the learning

environment and conditions learners to receive knowledge prepared for them. Therefore, the students’ efforts to create knowledge for themselves are constrained. Learners need to

develop cognitive processes and critical thinking; they ought to be exposed to learning environments that enhance construction of knowledge.

Social constructivists agree on the four characteristics, and the four characteristics have

implications for Cognitive education because social constructivist’s major principle is

“learners construct, rather than record, knowledge” (Eggen and Kauchak 2010, p. 230).

Other theorists believe “the view of the learner has changed from that of a recipient of

knowledge to that of a constructor of knowledge” (p. 230). The characteristics are discussed

below:

Four Characteristics of Social Constructivists

Learners are viewed as creating knowledge that makes sense to them and having control in

their learning. They are perceived as having changed from receiving knowledge from more

knowledgeable others to constructors of knowledge. Eggen and Kauchak (2010) proposed

that “Learners construct knowledge that makes sense to them” (p.230).

New learning depends on what the learners understand. Learning is perceived as meaningful

and social constructivists stress prior knowledge in facilitating learning. Eggen and Kauchak,

2010) suggested that, the emphases from social constructivists, learners develop thoughts to

construct knowledge and are embedded in the existing knowledge they have. Therefore, “new

learning depends on current understanding” (p.230).

Academic Research International ISSN-L: 2223-9553, ISSN: 2223-9944

Vol. 4 No. 6 November 2013

Part-II: Educational and Management Sciences SAVAP International

Copyright © 2013 www.savap.org.pk

www.journals.savap.org.pk

304

Learners are perceived as learning from each other and sharing ideas. Interacting with adults

or experienced peers students learn how to solve different kinds of problems. Thus, “Social

interaction facilitates learning” (Eggen and Kauchak (2010 p.230).

The internalization theory of Vygotsky proposed that children learn first by being engaged in

the activities under adult support and with time they continue to perform activities alone.

Therefore, the behavior will be viewed as first regulated socially by instruction of adults, and

then become regulated on their mental plane (Brynes, 2008).

The fourth idea that social constructivists suggested has an influence in learning is real- world tasks. Their perspectives on the above mentioned idea are rooted in situated cognition. They

proposed that most of what is learned is explicit to the setting in which “it is learned.” Anderson et al., (as cited in Eggen and Kauchak, 2010, p. 230). Real world tasks are also

called authentic tasks, learning activities where a student put into practice thinking that is

related to what is essential in the world Eggen & Kauchak, 2010).

Thinking is significant: Authentic activities are activities that promote thinking as well as problem –solving skills. Authentic activities are important in school and out of school setting.

“The most meaningful learning occurs within real-world tasks” (p.230). For example, when students use their knowledge of science to explain the importance of wearing seat belts when

driving; it is an example of including authentic learning activities (Eggen and kauchak 2010).

Situated cognition is related to the most meaningful learning discussed above. Learners are

perceived as ‘learning by participation’ borrowed from Lave & Wenger (1991). The school

setting is a place where learning is situated.

Situated Cognition

Situated cognition is vital in the social constructivist perspective; it implies that thinking is

situated in the social and physical environment not in the person’s mind (Santrock 2009). On one hand knowledge is rooted in, and related to the environment “in which the knowledge

is developed” (Santrock, 2009 p.350). The cognitive view perceives knowledge as possession while the socio-cultural sees knowledge as “belonging, participating and communicating”

Mason, 2007, p.3) Their explanations suggest that knowledge is not an ‘entity’ in the head of an individual, which the individual can obtain, develop or modify, but an action that cannot

be thought of as disconnected from the environment in which it takes place. The classroom is

“a community of learners” the teachers and students do joint work of learning together

aiming at assisting other individuals to achieve their goal in the learning environment Eggen

and Kauchak, 2010).

CONCLUSION

Direct instruction and social constructivism of knowledge differ in relation to student

learning. Direct instruction approach can contribute less input for learners in their

construction of knowledge. Direct instruction approach does not enhance much of

individual’s cognitive abilities. Social constructivists advocate for creation of learning

settings where learners share ideas and work in collaboration with each other solving

different problems they encounter as they learn.

The key element is the teacher has to make sure the type of learning where students construct

knowledge happens. Also, students are involved with others as they learn. They have the

chance of evaluating and improving their understanding through interaction and “exposed to

the thinking of others and as they participate in creating and understanding” (Santrock 2009,

p.350). When students interact and assist each other in learning; their cognitive abilities

Academic Research International ISSN-L: 2223-9553, ISSN: 2223-9944

Vol. 4 No. 6 November 2013

Part-II: Educational and Management Sciences SAVAP International

Copyright © 2013 www.savap.org.pk

www.journals.savap.org.pk

305

increase and are free as the learning environment becomes conducive. It is cooperative work

and learning. Cooperative learning happens when students are engaged in small groups

helping each other in the learning setting. Students are encouraged to work in pairs or groups

not exceeding four members. Ashman and Conway, 1997) add “the aim is to ensure that students work together to maximize their own and other group members’ learning” (p. 143).

The four characteristics social constructivists agree on stress that learners create meaningful

knowledge. When learners create knowledge that makes sense is motivated to learn by them.

Situated cognition is significant in the social construction of knowledge, it implies that

thinking is located (situated) within the social and physical environment not within the

learner’s mind. The learner’s knowledge is “embedded in” attached to the environment where

knowledge is developing. (Santrock, 2009, p. 350)

REFERENCES

[1] Ashman, F. & Conway, R. N. F. (1997) an introduction to cognitive education: theory

and applications. London: Routledge.

[2] Brynes, J. P. (2008) Cognitive development and learning: instructional contexts.

London: Pearson, Educational Inc.

[3] Eggen, P. & Kauchak, D. (2010) Educational psychology: windows on classroom

(eight edition). London: Pearson Education, Inc.

[4] Lave J. & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: legitimate peripheral participation.

Cambridge: University Press.

[5] Manson, L. (2007) Introduction: bridging the cognitive and socio-cultural approaches

in research on conceptual change: is it feasible? Educational psychologist, 42(1), 1-7.

[6] Santrock, J. W. (2009) Educational psychology (4 th Edition). London: Mc Graw- Hill.

[7] Slavin, R. E. (2012). Educational psychology (10 th

edition). London: Pearson.

[8] Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in the society: the development of higher psychological

processes. Harvard University Press.

AUTHOR’s PROFILE

Dr. Waitshega Tefo Smitta Moalosi is a Senior Lecturer in the Department of Educational Foundations, University of Botswana. She teaches courses in Educational Psychology. Dr.

Moalosi started teaching in the University of Botswana in January, 2000 as a Staff

Development Fellow (SDF).

Dr. Moalosi holds the following qualifications: a) PhD in Educational Psychology and Research, University of Tennessee, Knoxville (USA), b) M.ED Psychology of Education,

Bristol University, (England UK), c) BSc Psychology, Bolton Institute of Higher Education (England UK). Diploma in Counseling Studies, Keele University, (England UK). d)Primary

Teachers Certificate, Serowe Teacher Training College, Botswana.

Smitta’s research interests are: Teacher efficacy and classroom management, reasons for

choosing teaching as a career, self- concept and adolescent development.

Educational Psychology: Theory and Practice

Twelfth Edition

Chapter 7

The Effective Lesson

If this PowerPoint presentation contains mathematical equations, you may need to check that your computer has the following installed:

1) MathType Plugin

2) Math Player (free versions available)

3) NVDA Reader (free versions available) 

Organizing Questions

What Is Direct Instruction?

How Is a Direct Instruction Lesson Taught?

How Does Research on Direct Instruction Methods Inform Teaching?

How Do Students Learn and Transfer Concepts?

How are Discussions Used in Instruction?

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

What Is Direct Instruction?

At times, the most effective and efficient way to teach students is for you to present information, skills, or concepts in a direct fashion.

The term direct instruction is used to describe lessons in which you transmit information directly to students, structuring class time to reach a clearly defined set of objectives as efficiently as possible.

Direct instruction is particularly appropriate for teaching a well-defined body of information or skills that all students must master.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

How Is a Direct Instruction Lesson Taught?

The general lesson structure is vastly different in different subject areas and different grade levels.

The sequence of activities in direct instruction flows along a logical path:

arousing student interest

presenting new information

allowing students to practice their new knowledge or skills

assessment

This orderly progression is essential to direct instruction at any grade level and in any subject, although various components look different for different subjects and grades.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

State Learning Objectives

The first step in presenting a lesson is to state learning objectives and orient students to the lesson.

Tell students what they will be learning and what performance will be expected of them.

Whet students’ appetites for the lesson by informing them how interesting, important, or personally relevant it will be to them.

Give an astonishing or exciting opener that gets kids eager to learn the content.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Review Prerequisites

For the next major task in a lesson, you need to ensure that students have mastered prerequisite skills.

Go over any skills or concepts students need in order to understand the lesson.

Link information that is already in their minds to the information you are about to present.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Present New Material

Here begins the main body of the lesson, the point at which you present new information or skills.

In this step you teach the lesson by:

presenting information

giving examples

demonstrating concepts

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Conduct Learning Probes

Effective teaching requires you to be constantly aware of the effects of your instruction.

In this stage you conduct learning probes.

The term learning probe refers to any of a variety of ways of asking for brief student responses to lesson content.

To conduct a learning probe you will pose questions to students to assess their level of understanding and correct misconceptions.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Provide Independent Practice

The term independent practice refers to work students do in class on their own to practice or express newly learned skills or knowledge.

In this step of the lesson you will give students an opportunity to practice new skills or use new information on their own.

Independent practice is most critical when students are learning skills, such as mathematics, reading, grammar, composition, map interpretation, or a foreign language.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Assess Performance and Provide Feedback

Every lesson should contain an assessment of the degree to which students have mastered the objectives set for the lesson.

You should assess the effectiveness of the lesson and give the results of the assessment to students as soon as possible.

Steps in this process:

review independent practice work or give a quiz

give feedback on correct answers

reteach skills if necessary

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Provide Distributed Practice and Review

Practice or review spaced out over time increases retention of many kinds of knowledge.

Steps in this process:

assign homework to provide distributed practice on the new material

in later lessons, review material

provide practice opportunities to increase the chances that students will remember what they learned and also be able to apply it in different circumstances

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

How Does Research on Direct Instruction Methods Inform Teaching?

Most of the principles of direct instruction discussed in this chapter have been derived from process-product studies in which observers record the teaching practices of teachers whose students consistently achieve at a high level.

Although the research on direct instruction models has produced mixed conclusions, most researchers agree that the main elements of these models are essential minimum skills that all teachers should have.

Copyright © 2018,2015,2012 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved

How do Students Learn and Transfer Concepts?

A very large proportion of all lessons focus on teaching concepts.

A concept is an abstract idea that is generalized from specific examples.

Concepts are generally learned in one of two ways:

most concepts we learn outside of school we learn by observation

other concepts are typically learned by definition: for example it is very difficult to learn the concept Aunt or Uncle through observation

Copyrig

Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers

Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.

Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS

Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?

Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.

We write plagiarism Free Content

Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.

Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.