When you read the Deloitte paper you see some ‘ethics washing’ taking place. Where is it specifically? Section 2: How is Deloitte focusing its revenue stream in this particular topic?

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/234824743

Meta Ethics for the Metaverse: The Ethics of Virtual Worlds

Article · January 2008

CITATION

1 READS

6,232

1 author:

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Ethics of Technology View project

Edward H. Spence

The University of Sydney

49 PUBLICATIONS   201 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by Edward H. Spence on 20 May 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.

! "

Meta Ethics for the Metaverse: The Ethics of Virtual Worlds

Edward H. Spence

Abstract

#$%&'!(!)'*&$!*+%',-./%*,+!%0(%!1&%1!,.%!%0&!,2&'(33!('4.5&+%!,$!%0&!6(6&'!*+!1.55('78!%0&!$*'1%!

6('%!,$!6(6&'!9*33!,$$&'!(!5&%(:&%0*/(3!$'(5&9,';!)(1&-!,+!%0&!5,'(3!%0&,'7!,$!#3(+!<&9*'%08!

+&/&11('7!$,'!-&%&'5*+*+4!90(%8!*$!(+78!,.40%!%,!)&!%0&!&%0*/1!%0(%!4.*-&!%0&!/,+-./%!,$!6&,63&!

6('%*/*6(%*+4!*+!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!*+!%0&*'!',3&1!(1!-&1*4+&'18!(-5*+*1%'(%,'1!(+-!63(7&'1!,'!(2(%('1=!!

#1!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!(+-!%0&!>,'3-!>*-&!>&)!4&+&'(3378!*1!43,)(3!*+!*%1!1/,6&8!'&(/0!(+-!.1&8!!

<&9*'%0?1!%0&,'7!90*/0!,$$&'1!(!1.6'&5&!6'*+/*63&!,$!5,'(3*%78!%0&[email protected]'*+/*63&!,$!<&+&'*/!

A,+1*1%&+/[email protected]<AC!%0(%!&1%()3*10&1!.+*2&'1(3!'*40%1!$,'!(33!6&'1,+1!(39(71!(+-!&2&'790&'&8!*1!

6('%*/.3('37!1.*%()3&!$,'!%0*1!%(1;=!D0&!6(6&'!9*33!10,9!%0(%!6&'1,+1!),%0!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-!(+-!

*+!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!0(2&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4=!E%'*/%37!9*%0!'&4('-!%,!agency!%0,1&!

'*40%1!('&!5&'&37!6'*5(!$(/*&!).%!9*%0!'&4('-!%,!personhood!$'(5&-!(',.+-!%0&!+,%*,+!,$!self-

respect %0,1&!'*40%1!('&!()1,3.%&=!!

!

D0&!1&/,+-!6('%!,$!%0&!6(6&'8!90*/0!*1!6'&1/'*6%*2&!(+-!&2(3.(%*2&8!9*33!&F(5*+&!*+!5,'&!

6'(/%*/(3!-&%(*3!907!(+-!0,9!-&1*4+&'18!(-5*+*1%'(%,'1!(+-!(2(%('1!,$!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!('&!

'(%*,+(337!/,55*%%&-!,+!%0&!)(1*1!,$!%0&*'!,9+!*+%'*+1*/!6.'6,1*2&!(4&+/7!%,!&%0*/(3!+,'51!,$!

/,+-./%!%0(%!'&G.*'&!%0&!.+*2&'1(3!'&16&/%!,$!%0&!'*40%1!,$!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33:)&*+4!,$!(33!

(4&+%18!*+/3.-*+4!%0&*'!,9+=!!H1*+4!#3(+!<&9*'%0?1!('4.5&+%!$,'!%0&[email protected]'*+/*63&!,$!<&+&'*/!

A,+1*1%&+/7!BReason and Morality8!"IJKC!(+-!57!&F6(+-&-!('4.5&+%!$,'!%0&[email protected]<A!*+!57!

Ethics Within Reason: A Neo-Gewirthian Approach!BLMMNC8!%0&!6(6&'!9*33!16&/*$*/(337!1&&;!%,!

-&5,+1%'(%&!%0(%!*+1,$('!(1!(2(%('1!('&!&F%&+1*,+1!,$!'&(3!6&,63&!(+-!%0.1!/(+!(+-!5.1%!)&!

6&'/&*2&-!(1!2*'%.(3!6.'6,1*2&!(4&+%18!%0&+!%0&7!0(2&!5,'(3!'*40%1!(+-!,)3*4(%*,+1!1*5*3('!%,!

%0,1&!,$!%0&*'!'&(3!/,.+%&'6('%1=!E6&/*$*/(3378!%0&7!('&!'(%*,+(337!/,55*%%&-!%,!'&16&/%*+4!%0&!

4&+&'*/!'*40%1!,$!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!,$!(33!,%0&'!2*'%.(3!(2(%('18!(1!%0&*'!,9+!5.1%!)&!

'&16&/%&-=!!D0&!6(6&'!9*33!(31,!10,9!0,9!/,+$3*/%1!%0(%!5(7!('*1&!)&%9&&+!%0&!'*40%1!,$!

-*$$&'&+%!(2(%('1!(1!9&33!(1!/,+$3*/%1!%0(%!5(7!('*1&!)&%9&&+!%0&!'*40%1!,$!(2(%('1!,+!%0&!,+&!

0(+-!(+-!%0,1&!,$!(-5*+*1%'(%,'1!(+-!-&1*4+&'1!,+!%0&!,%0&'!/(+!*+!6'*+/*63&!)&!'&1,32&-=!!

O*+(3378!%0&!6(6&'!9*33!10,9!0,9!%0&!'.3&1!,$!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!(1!*+1%(+%*(%&-!)7!%0&!-&1*4+&'1?!

/,-&!(+-!%0&!(-5*+*1%'(%,'1?!&+-:.1&'!3*/&+1&!(4'&&5&+%!BPHQ#C8!5.1%!(39(71!)&!/,+1*1%&+%!

9*%0!(+-!/,5637!9*%0!%0&!'&G.*'&5&+%1!,$!.+*2&'1(3!5,'(3*%7!(1!&1%()3*10&-!,+!%0&!)(1*1!,$!%0&!

@<A=!>0&+!%0&!%9,!/,5&!*+%,!/,+$3*/%8!%0&[email protected]<A8!(1!%0&!1.6'&5&!6'*+/*63&!,$!5,'(3*%78!*1!

(39(71!,2&''*-*+4=!!!

!

!

1. Introduction: the Overall Argument of the Paper in Summary

O,'!%0&!6.'6,1&!,$!%0*1!6(6&'!R!10(33!-&$*+&!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!(1!S6&'1*1%&+%8!/,56.%&':5&-*(%&-!

&+2*',+5&+%1!*+!90*/0!(!63.'(3*%7!,$!63(7&'1!/(+!*+%&'(/%!9*%0!%0&!9,'3-!(+-!&(/0!,%0&'T!

BU('%3&!LMMNV!W"C=!Second Life8!EverQuest8!Dark Age of Camelot8!The Sims Online8!Ultima

Online8!Star War Galaxies8!Lineage!(+-!%0&!World of WarCraft, (5,+4!5(+7!,%0&'18!('&!1./0!

2*'%.(3!9,'3-1=!X,!63(7&'1!,$!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!(+-!%0&*'!(2(%('!'&6'&1&+%(%*2&1!*+!%0,1&!9,'3-1!

0(2&!'*40%1Y!R+!%0*1!6(6&'!R!10(33!('4.&!%0(%!%0&7!-,=!D(;*+4!57!/.&!$',5!Z(360![,1%&'?1!

S-&/3('(%*,+!,$!%0&!'*40%1!,$!(2(%('1T!B[,1%&'!!LMMNV!\:NC!R!10(33!)(1&!57!/3(*5!,+!#3(+!

<&9*'%0?1!('4.5&+%!$,'!%0&[email protected]'*+/*63&!,$!<&+&'*/!A,+1*1%&+/[email protected]<AC!90*/0!-&5,+1%'(%&1!%0(%!

(33!6.'6,1*2&!(4&+%1!0(2&!generic rights %,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!B<&9*'%08!"IJKC=!R!10(33!

! L

(-,6%!%0(%!('4.5&+%!%,!-&5,+1%'(%&!%0(%!*+1,$('!(1!(2(%('1!/(+!)&!2*&9&-!(1!%0&!2*'%.(3!

'&6'&1&+%(%*,+1!,$!%0&!6&'1,+1!%0(%!*+1%(+%*(%&!%0&5!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-8!(+-!%0&1&!6&'1,+1!0(2&!

4,(31!,'!6.'6,1&1!90*/0!%0&7!1&&;!%,!$.3$*33!9*%0*+!%0&!&+2*',+5&+%1!,$!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!%0',.40!

%0&*'!(2(%('18!%0&+!%0&7!(+-!)7!&F%&+1*,+!%0&*'!(2(%('1!('&!(/%*+4!6.'6,1*2&37!(+-!(1!1./0!0(2&!

'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4=!D0&1&!'*40%18!)&*+4!,+37!6'*5(!$(/*&!*563*&1!%0(%!%0&7!/(++,%!

)&!.1&-!)7!(4&+%1!,'!%0&*'!(2(%('1!%,!2*,3(%&!%0&!3&4*%*5(%&!'*40%1!,$!,%0&'!6.'6,1*2&!(4&+%1!,'!

%0&*'!(2(%('1=!>0&+!/,+$3*/%1!('*1&!)&%9&&+!%0&!'*40%1!,$!,+&!(4&+%!B0&+/&$,'%08!.+3&11!

,%0&'9*1&!1%(%&-8!R!10(33!.1&!%0&!*+/3.1*2&!%&'5!S(4&+%T!%,!'&$&'!%,!),%0!%0&!'&(3!6&'1,+!(+-!

%0&*'!2*'%.(3!'&6'&1&+%(%*,+8!%0&*'!(2(%('C!(+-!%0,1&!,$!(+,%0&'8!R!10(33!('4.&!%0(%!%0&1&!/,+$3*/%1!

/(+!)&!'&1,32&-8!(%!3&(1%!*+!!6'*+/*63&8!,+!%0&!)(1*1!,$!<&9*'%0?1!1.66,'%*+4!('4.5&+%!$,'!%0&!

X&4'&&!,$!%0&!]&/&11*%7!$,'!#/%*,[email protected]'*+/*63&!BX]#!6'*+/*63&C!%0(%!1%(%&1!%0(%!(4&+%!#?1!'*40%1!

10,.3-!%(;&!6'*,'*%7!,2&'!%0,1&!,$!(4&+%!U?1!90&+!%0&!,)^&/%1!,$!%0,1&!'*40%18!+(5&378!$'&&-,5!

(+-!9&33)&*+48!('&!5,'&!+&/&11('7!$,'!6.'6,1*2&!(/%*,+!(+-!1.//&11$.3!(/%*,+!*+!6('%*/.3('!

%0(+!%0&7!('&!9*%0!'&4('-!%,!%0,1&!,$!(4&+%!U?1=!

!

!R!10(33!('4.&8!5,'&,2&'8!%0(%!(3%0,.40!,+37!6'*5(!$(/*&!9*%0!'&4('-!%,!(4&+/78!'*40%1!%,!

$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!)&/,5&!()1,3.%&!(+-!*+(3*&+()3&!90&+!%0&7!'&$&'!%,!%0&!-*4+*%7!,$!

6&'1,+1=!!D0.1!(3%0,.40!(+!(4&+%?1!(2(%('!/,.3-!)&!^.1%*$*&-!*+!2*,3(%*+4!BR!10(33!'&$&'!%,!(!

^.1%*$*&-!2*,3(%*,+!,$!'*40%1!(1!(+!infringementC!%0&!4&+&'*/!'*40%1!,$!(+,%0&'!(4&+%?1!(2(%('!)7!

;*33*+4!%0&5!*+!(!-.&3!,'!/,5)(%!3&%!.1!1(78!&16&/*(337!90&+!%0&!/,-&!,$!%0&!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!(+-!

PHQ#!(33,91!$,'!%0(%!%,!0(66&+!,'!(%!3&(1%!-,&1!+,%!-*1(33,9!*%8!+,!(4&+%!*1!&2&'!^.1%*$*&-!*+!

2*,3(%*+4!%0&!'*40%1!,$!(+,%0&'!(4&+%!)7!.+-&'5*+*+4!%0&*'!-*4+*%7!,'!1&3$:'&16&/%!)7!1,5&!

9*-&37!'&/,4+*_&-!(/%!,$!-&4'(-(%*,+!,'!-&+*4'(%*,+8!1./0!(1!'(/*(3!2*3*$*/(%*,+!,'!'(6&8!$,'!

&F(563&=!#3%0,.40!'(6&!.+-,.)%&-37!2*,3(%&1!%0&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!,$!*%1!

2*/%*5!(+-!*1!%0&'&$,'&!.+&%0*/(3!,+!%0(%!1/,'&!(3,+&8!*%!5(7!+,%!(39(71!/(.1&!(+7!1*4+*$*/(+%!

6071*/(3!0('5!%,!%0(%!(4&+%8!(1!*%!9,.3-8!$,'!&F(563&8!*$!%0&!(4&+%!1.$$&'&-!(!6071*/(3!(11(.3%!

%0(%!'&1.3%&-!*+!%0&!)(10*+4!,'!1%())*+4!,$!%0&!(4&+%=!`,9&2&'8!*+1,$('!(1!'(6&!/(+!B*+!1,5&!

16&/*$*&-!1&+1&C!%(;&!63(/&!*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-8!%0&!2*/%*5!,$!1./0!2*'%.(3!'(6&!5(7!)&!

617/0,3,4*/(337!(+-!&5,%*,+(337!0('5&-!%,!1./0!(+!&F%&+%!%0(%!%0&7!('&!5(-&!%,!$&&3!

-&4'(-&-=!R+!1./0!(!/(1&8!%0&!'(6&-!(4&+%?1!1&+1&!,$!-*4+*%7!(+-!1&3$:9,'%0!(1!(!6&'1,+!5(7!)&!

1&'*,.137!*56(*'&-=!!R+1,$('!(1!'(6&!90&%0&'!'&(3!,'!2*'%.(3!-&4'(-&1!(!6&'1,+?1!-*4+*%7!(1!(!

6&'1,+8!'(6&!2*,3(%&1!+,%!,+37!%0&!6'*5(!$(/*&!4&+&'*/!'*40%1!,$!(!6&'1,+!G.(!(4&+%!).%!(31,!

%0&*'!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%,!%0&*'!1&3$:'&16&/%!G.(!6&'1,+!9,'%07!,$!*+0&'&+%!'&16&/%=!D0*1!*1!%0&!

4'&(%&'!0('5!%,!%0&!2*/%*51!,$!'(6&!(+-!,+&!,$!%0&!5,1%!1&'*,.1!5,'(3!9',+41!%0(%!,+&!6&'1,+!

/(+!*+$3*/%!,+!(+,%0&'=!!!

!

R!10(33!('4.&!%0(%!*+!4&+&'(38!%0&!/,-&!,$!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!Ba>C!%,4&%0&'!9*%0!*%1!PHQ#!5(7!

(33,9!,'!(%!3&(1%!+,%!-*1(33,9!2*'%.(3!S/'*5&1T!1./0!(1!%0&$%!,'!;*33*+4!%0(%!*+$'*+4&!(+!(2(%('1?!

'*40%18!6',2*-&-!%0,1&!2*'%.(3!/'*5&1!('&!*+!;&&6*+4!9*%0!%0&!(//&6%&-!'.3&1!,$!%0&!4(5&!63(7&-!

*+!%0(%!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!*+!(//,'-(+/&!9*%0!%0&!a>?1!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#=!`,9&2&'8!(!/,-&!,'!

PHQ#!10,.3-!+&2&'!(33,9!(+-!5.1%!(39(71!-*1(33,9!2*'%.(3!/'*5&1!*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!,'!,%0&'!

(/%1!%0(%!-&4'(-&!,'!/(+!6,%&+%*(337!-&4'(-&!%0&!-*4+*%7!,$!(+!(2(%('?1!6&'1,+8!1./0!(1!2*'%.(3!

'(6&!$,'!&F(563&8!&2&+!*$!%0*1!*1!*+%&+-&-!(1!5&'&37!6('%!,$!(!4(5&!9*%0*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-=!

>*%0!'&4('-!%,!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%0(%!(!6&'1,+!0(1!%,!,+&?1!-*4+*%78!5,'(3*%7!)&%9&&+!%0&!'&(3!

9,'3-!(+-!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!*1!(39(71!6&'5&()3&!(+-!6,',.18!(3%0,.40!*%!5(7!)&!3&11!1,!*+!%0&!

/(1&!,$!/'*5&1!%0(%!(3%0,.40!5(7!*+$'*+4&!(+!(2(%('?1!4&+&'*/!'*40%1!*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-8!1./0!(1!

%0&$%!(+-!;*33*+48!-,!+,%!2*,3(%&!).%!5(*+%(*+!'&16&/%!$,'!%0&!(2(%('?1!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%,!%0&*'!

-*4+*%7!(1!(!6&'1,+8!90*/0!)7!&F%&+1*,+!'&$&'1!%,!%0&!-*4+*%7!,$!%0&!6&'1,+!%0(%!*+1%(+%*(%&1!%0&!

(2(%('!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'-=!D0.1!/,+%'('7!%,!P-9('-!A(1%',+,2(!B!A(1%'(+,2(!LMMNV!JIC!R!9*10!%,!

('4.&!%0(%!5,'(337!16&(;*+4!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!/(+!+&2&'!)&!S/3,1&-T!9*%0!'&4('-!%,!90(%!($$&/%1!

! W

,'!/,.3-!6,%&+%*(337!($$&/%!%0&!6&'1,+(3!-*4+*%7!,$!(2(%('1!(+-!%0&*'!6&'1,+1!B%0&!6&'1,+1!90,!

*+1%(+%*(%&!%0&5!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-C=!D0&'&!*18!*+!(+,%0&'!9,'-18!!+,!!5,'(3!magic circle!(1!6&'!

A(1%'(+,2(!BA(1%'(+,2(!LMMNV!NKC!1&6('(%*+4!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!$',5!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-8!16&/*$*/(337!

9*%0!'&4('-!%,!%0&!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%0(%!(4&+%1!0(2&!%,!%0&*'!-*4+*%7!(1!6&'1,+18!),%0!9*%0*+!(+-!

9*%0,.%!%0&!),.+-('*&1!,$!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1=!>*%0!'&4('-!%,!5,'(3*%7!).%!+,%!(39(71!9*%0!'&4('-!

%,!%0&!3(98!%0&'&!*1!(+!&%0*/(3!/,+%*+..5!%0(%!'.+1!)&%9&&+!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!(+-!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-=!

#+!*+1.3%!%0(%!/(.1&1!,$$&+/&!/(+!)&!^.1%!(1!0.'%$.3!9*%0*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!(1!*%!/(+!*+!(!'&(3!

9,'3-=!#+!*+1.3%!/(+!6,%&+%*(337!)&!5,'(337!real *+!),%0!9,'3-1=!!

!

R!(5!*+!(4'&&5&+%!9*%0!b(/;!U(3;*+!%0(%!S%0&!),.+-('*&1!)&%9&&+!%0&!4(5&!16(/&!(+-!'&(3!

16(/&!('&!6&'5&()3&T!BU(3;*+!LMMNV!I"C=!`,9&2&'8!(-,6%*+4!(!5*–3&!6,1*%*,+!)&%9&&+!

P-9('-!A(1'(+,2(!(+-!b(/;!U(3;*+8!R!/3(*5!%0(%!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!/(+!.+-&'!(66',6'*(%&!

interration laws!BA(1%'(+,2(!LMMNC!(1!*+1%(+%*(%&-!)7!%0&!2*'%.(3!9,'3-?1!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#!

(33,9!$,'!1,5&!/3,1.'&!%0(%!'&+-&'1!(2(%('1!%0(%!1%&(3!$',5!,'!;*33!,%0&'!(2(%('18!*55.+&!$',5!

),%0!5,'(3!/.36()*3*%7!(+-!3&4(3!1(+/%*,+8!&16&/*(337!*$!1./0!(/%*,+1!('&!(//&6%&-!)7!%0&!

(2(%('1!%0&51&32&1!(1!)&*+4!6('%!,$!%0&!4(5&!16(/&!(+-!4(5&!63(+!,$!%0&!a>=!!R+!&F&'/*1*+4!

%0&*'!'*40%!%,!$'&&!(11,/*(%*,+!(+-!%0&!'*40%!%,!$'&&-,5!%,!63(7!*+!2*'%.(3!9,'3-1!%0(%!*+!%0&*'!

2*&9!&+0(+/&1!),%0!%0&*'!1&+1&!,$!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+48!(2(%('1!5(7!/0,,1&!%,!9(*2&!%0&*'!

6'*5(!$(/*&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!%0(%!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-!9,.3-!6'&/3.-&!,%0&'1!$',5!

1%&(3*+4!$',5!%0&5!(+-!&2&+!;*33*+4!%0&5=!>*%0*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!1./0!(/%*,+1!5(7!)&!

6&'5*%%&-!(1!)&*+4!6('%!,$!%0&!S4(5&T!(+-!%0.1!5,'(337!(//&6%()3&!9*%0*+!%0& role morality!,$!

%0&!a>=!`,9&2&'8!+,%0*+4!9*%0*+!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!%0(%!*+!1,5&!9(7!-&4'(-&1!%0&!6&'1,+(3!

-*4+*%7!,$!(+!(2(%('8!1./0!(1!'(6&8!$,'!&F(563&8!5(7!)&!6&'5*%%&-8!&2&+!90&+!*%!*1!*+!

(//,'-(+/&!9*%0!%0&!',3&!5,'(3*%7!,$!%0&!a>!(1!*+1%(+%*(%&-!)7!%0&!a>?1!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#8!(1!

%0*1!9,.3-!(33,9!%0&!2*,3(%*,+!,$!%0&!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!,$!(2(%('18!90*/0!*1!+&2&'!(//&6%()3&=!!

D0.1!(!a>!90,1&!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#!(33,91!'(6&!(1!6('%!,$!*%1!4(5&!1%'./%.'&!*1!+&2&'!5,'(337!

(//&6%()3&!(1!%0*1!/,+1%*%.%&1!(!2*,3(%*,+!,$!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!9*%0!

'&4('-!%,!6&'1,+(3!-*4+*%7!%0(%!%0&!(2(%('1!%0&51&32&1!/(++,%!()',4(%&!,'!9(*2&8!&*%0&'!

(/%.(337!,'!175),3*/([email protected]&'1,+(3!-*4+*%7!(1!*+1%(+%*(%&-!)7!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!

9&33)&*+48!&*%0&'!*+!%0&!'&(3!9,'3-!,'!*+!2*'%.(3!9,'3-18!*1!(39(71!(+-!&2&'790&'&!+,+:

+&4,%*()3&8!(%!3&(1%!*+!6'*+/*63&=!!

!

>0(%!9,.3-!-&%&'5*+&!4&+&'(337!90&%0&'!(!2*'%.(3!/'*5&!*1!5,'(337!(//&6%()3&!,'!+,%!*1!

90&%0&'!%0&!/'*5&!*1!(!feature!,$!%0&!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!Ba>C!90*/0!*1!(33,9&-!,'!(%!3&(1%!+,%!

-*1(33,9&-!)7!%0&!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#!,$!%0&!a>!,'!(+!exploit, (!2*'%.(3!/'*5&!90*/0!*1!+,%!

(33,9&-!,'!&2&+!*+%&+-&-!%,!)&!(33,9&-!)7!&*%0&'!%0&!/,-&!(+-!%0&!PHQ#!,$!%0&!a>!BU('%3&!

LMMNV!cLC=!>0&+!&F63,*%1!/,5&!%,!3*40%8!%0&7!9,.3-!0(2&!%,!)&!1%,66&-!%0',.40!(+!(-^.1%5&+%!

%,!%0&!/,-&!,$!%0&!a>!%0.1!(33,9*+4!%0&!a>!%,!5(*+%(*+!*%1!'&3(%*2&!/3,1.'&!(4(*+1%!&F%&'+(3!

5,'(3!(+-!3&4(3!1(+/%*,+1!(1!1.44&1%&-!)7!A(1%'(+,2(=!!

!

`,9&2&'8!(+!(–*%*,+(3!(+-!,2&''*-*+4!6',2*1,!%0(%!+&&-1!%,!)&!&560(1*_&-!*1!%0(%!%0&!/,-&!

(+-!PHQ#!,$!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!5.1%!(39(71!)&!/,+1*1%&+%!9*%0!(+-!+,%!/,+%'(2&+&!%0&!

'&G.*'&5&+%1!,$!%0&[email protected]'*+/*63&!,$!<&+&'*/!A,+1*1%&+/[email protected]<AC8!&16&/*(337!(1!%0&7!(6637!%,!

'&16&/%!$,'!%0&!()1,3.%&!'*40%1!%,!$'&&-,5!(+-!9&33)&*+4!%0(%!(33!(2(%('1!0(2&!9*%0!'&16&/%!%,!

%0&*'!-*4+*%7!(1!6&'1,+1=!D0.1!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-?1!/,-&!,'!PHQ#!*1!+&2&'!^.1%*$*&-!*+!/'&(%*+4!(!

role morality!$,'!*%1&3$!%0(%!/,+%'(2&+&1!%0&!.+*2&'1(3!5,'(3*%7!1.66,'%&-!)7!%0&[email protected]<A=!D0&!

3(%%&'8!)&/(.1&!.+*2&'1(3!(+-!$,.+-(%*,+(38!)&*+4!)(1&-!,+!%0&[email protected]<A!(1!%0&!1.6'&5&!6'*+/*63&!

,$!5,'(3*%78!9*33!(39(71!%(;&!5,'(3!6'*,'*%7!(+-!,2&''*-&!%0& role morality!,$!(+7!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!

%0(%!(33,91!$,'!&F(563&8!2*'%.(3!'(6&8!&2&+!%0,.40!%0*1!*1!(33,9&-!)7!*%1!*+%&''(%*,+!3(91!(1!

! c

*+1%(+%*(%&-!)7!*%1!/,-&!(+-!PHQ#=!R+!,%0&'!9,'-18!%0&!*+%&''(%*,+!3(91!,$!(!2*'%.(3!9,'3-!5.1%!

%0&51&32&1!)&!/,+1*1%&+%!9*%0!(+-!+,%!/,+%'(2&+&!%0&[email protected]<A=!!

!!!

2. The Rights of Agents: Alan Gewirth’s Argument for the Principle of Generic

Consistency 1

2.1 The Normative Structure of Action (Gewirth, 1978, 48–128) !

<&9*'%0?1!5(*+!%0&1*1!*1!%0(%!&2&'7!'(%*,+(3!(4&+%8!*+!2*'%.&!,$!&+4(4*+4!*+!(/%*,+8!*1!3,4*/(337!

/,55*%%&-! %,! (//&6%! (! 1.6'&5&!5,'(3! 6'*+/*63&8! %0&! @'*+/*63&! ,$!<&+&'*/! A,+1*1%&+/7=! D0&!

)(1*1!,$!0*1!%0&1*1!*1!$,.+-!*+!0*1!-,/%'*+&!%0(%!(/%*,+!0(1!(!+,'5(%*2&!1%'./%.'&8!(+-!)&/(.1&!,$!

%0*1! 1%'./%.'&! &2&'7! '(%*,+(3! (4&+%8! ^.1%! *+! 2*'%.&! ,$! )&*+4! (+! (4&+%8! *1! /,55*%%&-! %,! /&'%(*+!

+&/&11('7!6'.-&+%*(3!(+-!5,'(3!/,+1%'(*+%1=!

!

<&9*'%0!.+-&'%(;&1! %,!6',2&!0*1!/3(*5! %0(%!&2&'7!(4&+%8L!qua! (4&+%8! *1! /,55*%%&-! %,!/&&apo

Collepals.com Plagiarism Free Papers

Are you looking for custom essay writing service or even dissertation writing services? Just request for our write my paper service, and we'll match you with the best essay writer in your subject! With an exceptional team of professional academic experts in a wide range of subjects, we can guarantee you an unrivaled quality of custom-written papers.

Get ZERO PLAGIARISM, HUMAN WRITTEN ESSAYS

Why Hire Collepals.com writers to do your paper?

Quality- We are experienced and have access to ample research materials.

We write plagiarism Free Content

Confidential- We never share or sell your personal information to third parties.

Support-Chat with us today! We are always waiting to answer all your questions.